I’m a Haverford alum and as much as I love my alma mater, I would apply to Smith. Along with all of the positives on your D’s list, I would add a huge plus for their new president (Haverford Class of ‘86). She is an incredible leader, an intellect, and a joyful warm person. From all accounts Smith students have embraced “President Sarah” in a way that I’ve never seen.
Smith seems to be on a such a positive trajectory. Read this thread Smith STRIDE questions - ED advantage or disadvantage?