<p>Benefiting from several helpful suggestions in this thread, here's my latest (and perhaps last) iteration of the consensus list of noteworthy colleges, this time listing 131 noteworthy colleges, including all but one on the Barron's list of the most competitive colleges. </p>
<p>Allegheny College (PA) /CR
American University (DC) /CR
Amherst College (MA) **
Bard College (NY) /PBK, WM
Barnard College (NY) **
Bates College (ME) **
Boston College (MA) **
Boston University (MA)
Bowdoin College (ME) **
Brandeis University (MA) **
Brown University (RI) **
Bryn Mawr College (PA) /PBK
Bucknell University (PA)
California Institute of Technology (CA) /PBK, WM **
Carleton College (MN) **
Carnegie Mellon University (PA) **
Case Western Reserve University (OH) **
Centre College (KY)
Claremont McKenna College (CA) **
Colby College (ME) **
Colgate University (NY) **
College of New Jersey (NJ) /WM, CR **
College of William and Mary (VA) **
College of the Holy Cross (MA) **
Colorado College (CO)
Columbia University: Columbia College (NY) **
Columbia University: Fu Foundation School (NY) **
Connecticut College (CT) **
Cooper Union (NY) /PBK, WM **
Cornell University (NY) **
Dartmouth College (NH) **
Davidson College (NC) **
DePauw University (IN) /CR
Dickinson College (PA) /CR
Drew University (NJ) /WM, CR
Duke University (NC) **
Emory University (GA) **
Franklin and Marshall College (PA) /CR
Furman University (SC)
George Washington University (DC) **
Georgetown University (DC) **
Georgia Institute of Technology (GA) /PBK
Gettysburg College (PA)
Grinnell College (IA)
Gustavus Adolphus College (MN) /CR
Hamilton College (NY) **
Harvard University (MA) **
Harvey Mudd College (CA) /NW, PBK **
Haverford College (PA) **
Illinois Wesleyan University (IL) /CR
Iowa State University (IA) /CR
Johns Hopkins University (MD) **
Kalamazoo College (MI) /CR
Kenyon College (OH) **
Lafayette College (PA) **
Lawrence University (WI) /NW, CR
Lehigh University (PA) /WM
Macalester College (MN) **
Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MA) **
Miami University (OH) /WM
Middlebury College (VT) **
Mount Holyoke College (MA)
New College of Florida (FL) /PBK, WM
New York University (NY) **
Northwestern University (IL) **
Oberlin College (OH) **
Occidental College (CA) **
Pitzer College (CA) /PBK, WM
Pomona College (CA) **
Princeton University (NJ) **
Reed College (OR) **
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (NY) /PBK, CR
Rhodes College (TN) /WM
Rice University (TX) **
Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey (NJ)
Sarah Lawrence College (NY) /PBK, CR
Scripps College (CA) /WM **
Skidmore College (NY) /CR
Smith College (MA) **
Southwestern University (TX) /YD, CR
St. Olaf College (MN)
Stanford University (CA) **
State University of New York at Albany (NY) /Peterson, CR
State University of New York at Binghamton (NY)
State University of New York at Buffalo (NY) /CR
Swarthmore College (PA) **
Syracuse University (NY) /CR
Trinity College (CT) /CR
Tufts University (MA) /WM **
Tulane University (LA) /WM **
Union College (NY)
United States Air Force Academy (CO) /Fiske, PBK, WM
United States Military Academy (NY) /Fiske, NW, PBK, WM **
United States Naval Academy (MD) /Fiske, PBK, WM **
University of California: Berkeley (CA) **
University of California: Los Angeles (CA) **
University of California: San Diego (CA)
University of Chicago (IL) **
University of Dallas (TX) /WM
University of Florida (FL)
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (IL)
University of Miami (FL) /PBK, WM, CR **
University of Michigan (MI) /NW
University of Minnesota--Twin Cities (MN)
University of Missouri: Columbia (MO) /PR, CR
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (NC) **
University of Notre Dame (IN) **
University of Pennsylvania (PA) **
University of Pittsburgh (PA) /CR
University of Richmond (VA) /CR **
University of Rochester (NY) /PR **
University of Southern California (CA) **
University of Texas at Austin (TX)
University of Virginia (VA) **
University of Washington (WA)
University of Wisconsin--Madison (WI)
University of the South (TN)
Vanderbilt University (TN) **
Vassar College (NY) **
Villanova University (PA) /WM
Wabash College (IN) /WM
Wake Forest University (NC) /WM **
Washington University in St. Louis (MO) **
Washington and Lee University (VA) **
Wellesley College (MA) **
Wesleyan University (CT) **
Wheaton College (IL) /PBK
Whitman College (WA)
Willamette University (OR) /CR
Williams College (MA) **
Yale University (CT) ** </p>
<p>The double asterisks now mean exactly that the college is considered by Barron's to be "most competitive," and thus tells onlookers which colleges are most a "reach" to apply to. The other colleges on this list were mentioned at least six times in inclusion sources--there are eight of those as I have realigned my selection approach, sources 1) through 7) and source 9) above--and in the other selectivity source, source 8), Rugg's Recommendations on the Colleges. The selection principles are still debatable, as I would be the first to acknowledge, but I think this list is a little more plausible to me than my last attempt. Colleges that are not named by absolutely all sources are shown with the sources that omitted them, symbolized by abbreviations of the source title. </p>
<p>You'll see too that now states are listed for each college. As before, feel free to comment on anything that jumps out at you about this list.</p>