A Simple Grammar Question

<p>Which of the following would be correct as far as the use of "myself" and "me" are concerned. (Also, sidenote: is the comma necessary?)</p>

<p>He understood the concept, whereas Ben and younger version of myself did not.</p>

<p>He understood the concept, whereas Ben and younger version of me did not.</p>

<p>Danke sehr!</p>

<p>The first one looks right to me, but I'm not 100% sure</p>

<p>The sentence is grammatically ok as shown in the first version. The difference between myself and me in this case is mostly stylistic, and I think it's a bit better with "myself." Also, you might want a "the" in between "and" and "younger."</p>

<p>Haha, yes. The absence of "the" is merely a typo :)</p>

<p>The first sentence is NOT correct. "Myself" is a reflexive pronoun, and it should generally only be used if "I" comes before it in the sentence. :)</p>

<p>Thus, the correct sentence is:
He understood the concept, but Ben and the younger version of me did not. </p>

<p>or </p>

<p>He understood the concept, but Ben and the younger I did not.</p>

<p>warblers is correct; if it helps, I'd just like to add some more info:</p>

<p>Myself, like warblers said, is a reflexive pronoun. When the subject and the object of a sentence are the same, then the object must be in the reflexive case:</p>

<p>I gave it to myself.
I hit myself.
You understand yourself.
The dog chases itself.</p>

<p>(Excuse the sentences.)</p>

<p>It can also be used in the emphatic case:</p>

<p>I myself read the book.
I looked over it myself.</p>

<p>A general rule of thumb is that if you don't have an object, or, if you do, and the object is different from the subject, then you shouldn't be using a reflexive pronoun (I'm disregarding the emphatic case).</p>

<p>In this particular case, you are introducing a new clause, as you are using either the conjunction "whereas," or "but." A clause has its own subject and predicate.</p>

<p>Ben and younger version of myself did not (understand the concept).</p>

<p>Ben and you make up and the plural subject, and they should both be in the subjective case: I, you, he/she/it, we, you (pl.), they. This is what happens in warbler's example of "Ben and the younger I did not." However, in your example, you use the preposition "of," which requires the objective case:</p>

<p>of me
of you
of him/her/it
of us
of you (pl.)
of them
(of whom—just for fun.)</p>

<p>So, putting all of this together...</p>

<p>You start with your main clause: "He understood the concept,"
You introduce your subordinate clause with a conjunction, either "whereas," or "but."
You start with your subject, understanding when to use the subjective or objective pronoun: "Ben and the younger version of me," or "Ben and the younger I."
You complete your verb: "did not."</p>

<p>Throughout all of this you realize that you aren't using the objective or emphatic case, and therefore you don't need to use a reflexive pronoun.</p>

<p>So there are a lot of little things that go towards putting this sentence together. It's not exactly a simple grammar question if you disregard your ear and actually try and figure it all out :)</p>

<p>If I got anything wrong, please correct me.</p>

<p>Wow, thanks fellas.</p>