Can someone explain why appositives are needed, or not needed, and what is the difference for why or why not.
1.
In 1933, attorney and civic leader Luther Ely Smith envisioned a memorial that would recognize St. Louis’s major role in the westward expansion of the United States.
A) No Change
B) attorney, and civic leader
C) attorney and civic leader,
D) attornet, and civic leader,
The correct answer is A) no change. Why wouldn’t C be correct since there would be an APPOSTIVE if “Luther Ely Smith, attorney and civic leader,…”
2.
Coca-Cola began in 1886 when the spirt of an Atlanta pharmacist, Dr. John S. Pemberton, led him to create a drink.
Why is this correct. Doesn’t Dr. Pemberton identify who the Alanta Pharamicst is so why are commas needed.
3.
That was until I met, my calculus teacher, Ms. Sweed.
My boss, John Jacobs, was early that morning,
Why is an APPOSTIVE needed for 4 but not 3.
ANY HELP IS APPRECIATED. ESPECIALLY, IF YOU CAN EXPLAIN RHE DIFFERCENS AND WHY EACH CASE NEEDS OR DOES NOT NEED APPOSITIVES.