ACT Form 0359F Answer Explanation

I’m new to college confidential, so I don’t know if this is the right place to ask this, but I was wonder if someone could explain question #72 from the form 0359 practice ACT.

Link to question: http://cdn2.hubspot.net/hub/360031/file-2227156992-pdf/Documents/ACT_Test_2005-06.pdf?t=1468608503424 (page 24)

Question text: After sliding the shaft of the replacement feather over the sturdy, light bamboo stick, glue–just a touch is applied.

Replace “glue–just a touch-- is applied.” with:
F) NO CHANGE
G) a touch of glue is applied by the rehabilitator.
H) the application of a touch of glue follows.
J) the rehabilitator applies a touch of glue.

Why is the answer J, not G? Don’t both work?

The Subject has to come right after the comma. Otherwise it’s not clear who is doing the Sliding.

It is because J is in active voice whereas G is in passive voice. In J the subject is performing the verb. In G is unclear who is doing the application.

Other examples (from yourdictionary.com):
Harry ate six shrimp at dinner. (active)
At dinner, six shrimp were eaten by Harry. (passive)

Beautiful giraffes roam the savannah. (active)
The savannah is roamed by beautiful giraffes. (passive)

@CougarCatClan has it. After grammar principles are dealt with, style comes into play, and passive voice is less preferable than active.

Yup. Just think of it like this. if the answer was G, then the sentence would basically be saying that the “touch of glue” would be doing the sliding of the shaft of the feather onto the bamboo stick instead of the rehabilitator. And that certainly does not make sense.

Moving an introductory/modifying phrase to a new place in the sentence - right after after the subject - often helps
on questions of this type.
Compare:

A touch of glue, after sliding the shaft of the replacement feather over the sturdy, light bamboo stick, is applied by the rehabilitator.

The rehabilitator, after sliding the shaft of the replacement feather over the sturdy, light bamboo stick, applies a touch of glue.

Active over passive voice preference is an additional nail in the choice G’s coffin.

This is false and not how passive voice works.

Ex: The food was eaten by me
(does NOT mean the food is performing the action of eating!)