<p>Many MT professional actors, as well as many BFA MT students are very good at straight theater/acting. I do not agree that they are not equipped to do Shakespeare, etc. To the contrary, many who pursue MT, could have done a BFA in Acting program and/or are cast in straight dramas. They ALSO can sing and dance. It doesn't necessarily follow that they are not competitive in the straight acting venue. Just looking at BFA programs, I know that many BFA in MT students are cast in the straight dramas at their colleges. Look at the top BFA in MT graduates from CMU, for example, and you will see that many of them have very good acting credits from their time at CMU. At Tisch Mainstage shows, students from CAP21 are cast in straight dramas where they are competing against those in the BFA in Acting studios. Just to get into most BFA in MT programs, one must be able to act. My child was only trying for BFA in MT programs and didn't want straight acting, though she has been in several dramas. She was waitlisted for ACTING at CMU, so even a MT kid may have acting chops. My D's friend was recently on Broadway (while in HS) in a musical and she was about to enter Northwestern this fall but is deferring as she is cast in an upcoming off Broadway play starring a recent Tony winning actress. I've seen her as the lead in many musicals but she also is a terrific actress and does straight drama as well. </p>
<p>I think one reason that the degrees you see in the company at Oregon Shakespeare Festival do not include those with a BFA in MT isn't because those folks can't act but because those folks likely are not pursuing that company in the same proportion as someone with a straight acting degree would be. I can't say whether every MT actor is a great actor but certainly someone in MT can't be in it if they can only sing. Many ALSO do straight acting and do it very well. My child prefers MT because she loves to sing, dance and act, but certainly would consider straight acting jobs. She was called back this summer for a role in an Off Broadway play, and while her love is MT, she'd have considered taking it, believe me. </p>
<p>I also agree with Lisa and Eve that the quantity of hours spent in this or that class from one degree to another, doesn't necessarily equate with who is the better actor. BFA in Acting students take movement, voice/speech, mask, and such on top of acting. A BFA in MT student studies acting and then also dance and voice. Some people do a few things well and some do one thing very well. Just different sorts of people. </p>
<p>I don't quite agree with the ski analogy as you were talking EQUIPMENT, not training. My kid is a ski racer. She trains in Giant Slalom and Slalom (and yes, has separate ski equipment for each). She happens to do a bit better at GS than Slalom, but trains in both and competes in both. Her Slalom training clearly does NOT dilute her training in GS. To the contrary, she competes on a Div. I Varsity College team. Her results are often better in GS but I can tell you that NO coach would tell her to ONLY train GS. She trains and competes in both. My theater kid trains in singing, acting, and dance (sounds like your D who is pursuing BFAs in Acting ALSO trains now in singing and dance as well), and she will audition for both musicals and plays and has played leads in either genre. Will she opt to join a Shakespeare company like the one you are affiliated at? Likely not her first choice because as much as she likes to be in a play, she would not totally give up musical theater in sum to be in that company long term. I suppose anything is possible but she prefers to do both and if given a choice, would choose MT, though is skilled at and enjoys plays. I can think of so many people I know that are very good at MT and are even pursuing MT in college and beyond, who are ALSO very good actors who have done straight theater too.</p>
<p>PS, I feel odd about discussing this on an Otterbein thread but conversations tend to lead to this or that and Wally, you mentioned that your D is pursuing a BFA in Acting but would like some singing and dance. Some BFA in Acting degree programs offer that. For instance, at NYU/Tisch, Playwrights Horizons and Lee Strasberg studios offer some vocal and dance classes for the BFA Drama student. Some BFA in Acting schools have Dance Minors that are possible to do. Elon comes to mind with that. Perhaps USC.</p>