Congratulations on your hard work and success!
Now a question about the financial side, which is very important. A student might be able to afford $0 to $70,000 per year. Schools might cost anywhere on that spectrum (and even a little higher). So figuring out where you are and what schools are at or below that number is crucial. I’m assuming you are a PA resident, since there are 3 PA schools on your list . . . correct? Have you run the Net Price Calculators (NPCs) for these schools? How does it look? Are they affordable?
Why UF? Do you have ties there? You might be aware that it only has a very small % of OOS students–one of the smallest of all state flagships. (Florida prefers to reserve spots for in-state students; Michigan, Wisconsin, Alabama and other states welcome lots of OOS students.) So that makes Florida more competitive OOS.
To your question, Am I aiming too high? Can I suggest you think about it a little differently? What if you thought of it as, what kind of schools would be a good fit for ME? You seem to like large schools–that’s great. Along with that, are big-time sports important to you? All your schools have big-time sports, including Villanova basketball, obviously. Is that a draw for you?
So let’s say you think you’d like to study at a big-time state flagship with big-time sports. I don’t know the typical stats at these schools, but let’s say you make that 1400 and have a good spring semester, which would be helpful in any case. Well, apply to PSU, Pitt, Florida, and any others that appeal. Villanova, which has a great business school, too. Maybe you’ll get accepted to some or all of them. But you might also wanted to find a couple of similar schools–that work well for you–that have less competitive admissions, where you be happy to study, and, importantly, are affordable. I’d think of some of the midwestern flagships, like Kansas, Nebraska, Iowa, which are actually in college towns or even urban locations and offer pretty generous money to OOS students. So not all that different than PSU, Pitt, and Florida (except for the weather). And it’s important to understand that acceptance rate does not equal quality of education. The schools on your list are all terrific, and so are these schools and many others.
As noted in the above comment, students sometimes apply as direct admits in business schools, sometimes apply after studying for a while at school, some combo of both, or maybe something slightly different. The business school can be more competitive than general admission. So it’s good to be aware of that at the schools that interest you.
Good luck, and have fun with the process! You’ll do fine!