Am I overthinking this?

Already been stated but the Admitted Students day was very helpful to us. S was admitted into 8 schools. We had him cull down to 3 (pro and con list). Saw the schedules and could only swing 2 (annoying that many are on the same day!). Had him knock off the third and visited the two. He would have been happy at either but the day really swung the pendulum to the one that had the best fit for him. It was so clear. Academically virtually identical, but most other things leaned heavily to where he attends. You get a lot more detail at these days vs. regular tours. Get to sit in on classes, eat in the dining hall with current students, listen to speeches by the provost, visit with career services, study abroad, etc. Very valuable.