<p>This is the way our teacher taught us, and she also grades AP US history DBQs. I forgot who came up with this method (it was named after him), but i will try to remember the most I can. </p>
<p>After you read the question, the first thing you have to do is come up with at least 3 categories. Then try to fill in as much specific factual information you can think of and put them in your categories. It is important you do this before you read the documents, so you don't forget them when you are trying to analyze the documents. once you put down everything you remembered into the chart you made for your categories then start reading your documents. When looking at documents make sure to look for the author/painter/political cartoonist/historian (a lot of times the author will be famous, but the document they are citing won't). Sometimes the documents are meant to trigger the reader memory; like a first hand account of labor protest turned violent means they want you to recognize that they are probably talking about the Haymarket Square Riot. So after you figure out what the document is trying to say then write it down in the appropriate category (if it fits with your position put a plus next to it, if it doesn't put a negative). Make sure to note the letter of the document when you write down the point, because this makes it a lot easier when you are basically transposing all the information into essay form. Oh yeah, don't be afraid to use a point that is contradictory to your position, because you are supposed to acknowledge the complexities of history. Just try to make it fit into your position; for example if your position is that the American government did not do a lot to help African Americans after the Civil War and one of your documents is about the Freedmen's bureau then you could say something like: "even though the Freedmen's Bureau was created to deliver aid to freed slaves in the south, the majority of local Bureau agents were hindered in carrying out their duties by the opposition of former Confederates, the lack of a military presence to enforce their authority, and an excessive amount of paperwork."</p>
<p>When you finish with all the documents, it is time to write the thesis. I was told to never make the thesis more than two sentences. The AP graders are looking for structured papers that are easy to read/follow. What I do is the first sentence of the thesis states my position. My second sentence will usually define a key word (like Jacksonian democracy) and include my categories I used in the chart. Make sure you write the categories in your thesis in the same order you are going to talk about them in your essay. </p>
<p>For instance, if the question was: How successful was organized labor in improving the position of workers in the period from 1875 to 1900? Analyze the factors that contributed to the level of success achieved. Use the documents and your knowledge of the period from 1875 to 1900 to construct your response. (Did this one as a practice last year). Your first sentence could be; "Organized labor was insufficient in their attempts to improve the conditions of the lowly worker [stated position: were insufficient] during the Guilded Age [a lot of times they will give you a time period, it is your job to know what period it is by the dates they give you and the context of the question]." My second sentence included the time I was limiting my essay (make sure you keep this in mind when writing the essay, because you can not use events after 1900...this is important because the position of the worker wasn't elevated until after 1900), my categories, and what i am supposed to define. So the next sentence could be; "During 1875 to 1900 [time period], the poor position of workers [defined position as poor] were due to internal struggles with in labor unions, failed protests, and bad press (couldn't think of a better category...its been a while lol)."</p>
<p>Once you have your thesis the rest of the essay is easy. Every paragraph should have a introduction sentence that states the category you are talking about and your position on it. Then include the points in your chart you made, and try to make it flow together. The last sentence is the clincher sentence that finished off your thoughts on the category and provides a transition into the next one. When you are done just rephrase your thesis sentence for your conclusion.</p>
<p>BTW, if you feel your teacher is incompetent then try to see if another AP US history teacher is willing to read your DBQs/give you help.</p>