Xavier is the better option in this instance. The Advantage program sounds like a huge sham in all honesty. It’s much better to stay on ONE single campus for all four years. I wouldn’t recommend it, nor would I call Binghamton “top notch”. It’s good, but not at all top notch. Binghamton also is NOT the school for any decently athletic kid to attend. Xavier is a good school in its own right, and he will do very fine there. MBA programs care more about what you do while in college rather than the name of the college you attended.