Have you run the NPC on both? Neither is especially good for financial aid, so you shouldn’t invest too much “interest” and “likes” in them.
A student who wants an urban university and would consider these universities reachable in terms of stats, is likely to qualify for a scholarship at UMN Twin Cities, Macalester (meets need), DePaul, Loyola Chicago, Loyola LA, Loyola New Orleans, Tulane, UPitt, Temple, American, USC-Columbia…