Chance me

Varsity athlete
Peer leader
Performing arts, dance team-leader
9.5 GPA, all honors and AP classes
1800 SAT
girl from NYC suburb

?
Lehigh
Tufts
Middlebury
Cornell
Boston Univ
Haverford
Bates
Amherst
Wesleyan

SAT is 1850 not 1800. thanks.

Are you being recruited? With those SATs none of the schools you listed are realistic unless a coach wants you and can support you.

Two of your schools are test optional but unless your test scores are a true aberration, your chances especially as a female from the NY area are nonexistent.

What is a 9.5 gpa?

Your best shot would be to apply ED to Lehigh or BU. The others are all reaches/far reaches.

Didn’t proof that very well. oops. It’s a 95 GPA, not 9.5

@SteiStei Much more realistic:

Lehigh - Reach
Lafayette - Reach
Villanova - Reach

Below are likely:
Dickinson
Muhlenberg
Clark
Gettysburg
St. Lawrence
Union
Providence
Syracuse