3.49 GPA
Honors math and sciences
25 ACT
8 on the writing portion
Class President
2 Varsity Sports
Captain
Awarded Honors for Sports
Student Council Rep
100+ Community Service Hours
Private, Catholic
I think you have a decent chance of getting in. They probably just deferred you to see how competitive the other applicants are and are making final decisions now.
I agree with @jack8205, your stats seem pretty decent but I hear that the reason they are taking so long is because the quality and quantity of applicants has increased and they want to fill the slots wisely.