I am a current senior from northern Westchester in a prestigious high school and I just applied to Middlebury ED1. I have a a 32 on the ACT. My current courses are Honors French, AP Photography, Science Research (a 3 year college level research program), AP Biology, precalculus, and on-level English. Extracurricular activities: started my own business and donated $5000 to charities in my community, member of math and language honors societies, paid leadership position over past 2 summers, various volunteering committees for helping those younger than me, and 4 years as photographer for school newspaper. I have a 4.05 GPA and no class ranking; my school doesn’t weight/rank.
You certainly have the stats, scores, ECs and Grades. You are at a bit of a disadvantage due to your demographic. I think your chances are in the 80% range. Good luck!