<p>Artsymom, </p>
<p>While I can't say I have had that experience with my kid personally, I definitely understand the experiences you are relating with regard to your daughter. </p>
<p>First, stepping back BEFORE one applies to college, for a moment.....I think kids who love MT really need to think long and hard about the differences between a BFA and a BA path. I think too many kids are too quick to pick the BFA one when it may very well not be the right one for them, no matter how wonderfully talented they may be in that field. In fact, a lot of the guidance I attempt to give the students with whom I work really reviews this issue at the outset. A BFA is NOT for everyone. A person can be very passionate about MT and want to pursue or study it but a BFA is not the appropriate choice. A person who simply loves MT and wants to keep doing it, might be better off in a BA. A person who doesn't just love MT but IS MT HAS to do a BFA as no other route would feel right for them. One thing that I hear with many students is "I want options" or "I want fall backs" and so on and so forth. Already, my mind goes to "do a BA" which is where you can have options. Only seek a BFA if you are so certain of no other path. The slightest bit of uncertainty leads me to think that a BA path is more suitable for some kids. It doesn't mean giving up MT, but simply it allows them to change their mind, explore various options, have their desired "fallbacks", etc. A BFA is a HUGE commitment at a young age that truly requires knowing without a doubt that you can't exist without pursuing MT. A person who wants to study MT, can still do a BA, but the commitment for that more narrow path is not as set in stone. So, step one is figuring out which path fits the student best. </p>
<p>One thing is that it is very hard for a 17 year old to KNOW for CERTAIN what they want to do. In fact, that is what college can and is often about....exploring many things to figure out what you want to do. In fact, some subjects aren't even studied until college. I have a daughter who was NOT ready to commit at age 17 to a narrow path. She was interested in architecture but could not know for certain that she wanted to do that the rest of her life which is what she had to do if she picked a professional degree program for college (a five year BArch degree.....kinda like choosing a BFA in MT). It is not like she had been learning about architecture her entire life. Also, she wanted a broader education as she is interested in other subjects. She didn't want a huge chunk of her education to be in one area and to be all set with little choices. Thus she chose a BA path, a liberal arts degree in architecture, which will require a graduate professional degree (MArch) in order to become an architect (vs. the 5 year BArch degree she didn't do). As it turns out, she has decided to become an architect but she had the freedom to explore and change her mind. She also has been able to study other things and get a broad education like she wanted. I think college can and often should be, the place to explore and figure out what you want to do. </p>
<p>Her sister, however, who had done MT her whole life, however, KNEW what she wanted to do. It wasn't like a big decision to do it. It just WAS. It was not even discussed. She was certain of her path and only applied to BFA programs. However, as certain as she is of MT and loves doing a BFA, she did want a BFA school where there was some liberal arts because as she has stated "I love learning". She loves learning about other things too and in fact, that learning makes her a better actor, I'm sure. She is commited 100% to MT, but she likes other things. She didn't go into it wanting a back up but simply enjoys other subjects and skills. Her classes started yesterday and she was extremely excited to be taking Political Sociology of War and Playwriting, both of which interest her a lot. She is not doing these things as back up but simply because she enjoys them. She recently wrote a mini musical that is going to be put on, and loves the creative process. She enjoys musically directing, accompanying, choreographing, writing, arranging, along with performing. Her BFA has allowed her to do all these things. However, she still loves the BFA. Doing MT is just part of who she is and so it has been the right path.</p>
<p>However, I have seen at all of these BFA programs, many students who do not stay in the program. Many stay at their colleges but leave the BFA or some transfer all together. I think it is pretty common. What I observe is that once some have engaged in the BFA, they have come to realize that that is not the path for them, even if they still love MT and want to do MT. For some, it might be due to the intensity, hours, total commitment, etc. For some, they realize they are also interested in studying other things, maybe even more than MT. Again, that is what college is supposed to be about....figuring those things out. The problem (which isn't really a problem) is that the BFA path doesn't really allow one to do that. A BFA path is a commitment from the start (unless you leave the BFA). The college experience of exploring different subjects and determing your path doesn't come with the BFA "tag" but is really what a BA path allows. My daughter has seen several kids leave the BFA at NYU and switch into BA programs. She has a friend from home who started in the BFA at Emerson but opted out of the BFA to pursue the path she wants now which is still in performing arts but not as narrow as MT. What I see happening is that some students who chose a BFA are basically doing what college students do all the time, changing their major or focus. It is just that the BA path is more suited to that kind of exploration and changing and options. A BFA truly is not for everyone and it is a commitment from the outset to one narrow path (though I do believe a person who earns a BFA in MT is prepared to do many things). When I say "narrow path", I mean more a narrow path of study, not career. Some BFAs do allow for some liberal arts and so for those who still want to learn about other subjects even if they are certain of the BFA in MT, they should pick a BFA program that allows for some liberal arts (my kid cared about that). </p>
<p>So, I think what your daughter is experiencing is very common for COLLEGE students. A majority change their intended major once in college. She is having a typical experience for someone her age. It is just that the BFA is meant for those who are 100% certain (which is hard for many 17 year olds to be). I think your daughter would be fine to switch from her BFA to a BA and still pursue her love of MT, but be able to explore many things and even other careers. A BFA is not worth doing unless your heart and soul are deeply tied to doing it. It just involves a total commitment and is intense. I can't imagine doing all that unless you are so certain you could not dream of not doing it. A person in a BA can be very passionate about MT but enjoy other passions and not feel like it HAS to be MT or else. Switching to a BA doesn't mean giving up MT in one's life! I hope your daughter goes with wherever her heart leads her and I don't think she is giving up MT but simply giving up the BFA path because it likely isn't the right fit for where she is at at the present time. I think she is getting a lot out of college and in fact, due to her exploration, is figuring out what she wants to do which is what college really is about. The BFA thing is for those who didn't even have to figure it out but just KNOW without a doubt. Even some of those kids might have to switch out once they experience a BFA and realize it is not for them. They still can do MT. It is not like they are giving up MT itself.</p>