CMU SCS ($63k) vs. USC merit scholarship ($36k) for CS?

Colleges and Universities A-Z Carnegie Mellon University
1

I plan on studying computer science, and my future plans include maybe getting a masters or just working/researching in a company (depending on what specific focus I pursue). I have gone back and forth on this decision countless times, and I realize that I ultimately find USC a “happier” place, but I still have my doubts about what I’m giving up if I do choose USC. I have visited both schools, and I like both. I’d love to hear others’ input/perspective or additions to my pro/cons list :slight_smile:

Money is not the deciding factor, but of course I don’t want to take on loans + be unhappy. Ultimately, I think both schools are worth it. (Disclaimer: I know rankings/reputation is not everything, but there is still some sense in them when there is a pretty noticeable disparity.) Here are my thoughts:

PROS of USC: costs about $36k/yr

  • a great school, lovely weather/location overall, McCarthy housing
  • Viterbi fellow/scholar = research stipend, still lots of opportunity (and Viterbi overall is still small/focused)
  • Viterbi students are collaborative in nature

CONS of USC:

  • such a big school, the range of people here (in terms of academic motivation) is huge even within Viterbi
  • USC is not nearly as reputable/strong in CS
  • obviously not as much name recognition but that’s not an issue (except when CMU name recognition seems to really go beyond)

PROS of CMU: costs about $63k/yr (no FA)

  • the School of Computer Science - focus and depth on CS, great resources for everyone, small size but large presence on campus
  • lots of opportunity/recognition for everyone who puts in effort; favored greatly by employers
  • overall very collaborative, in general more hard-working/nerdy/serious students

CONS of CMU:

  • stress culture (yes, I realize not everyone is like stressed/depressed, but overall it still makes a big difference).
  • minor things: Pittsburgh weather
  • costs a heck ton more, but it seems like grads are able to quickly earn/return their loans and it is worth it
2

I paid full price for my kids’ college. I would pay for CMU. I can afford it however.

If your parents say they can afford it, then don’t let money stop you from going to the school you want. If you need to borrow $100K, then go to USC. It’s still an excellent school.

However, if you actually prefer USC for whatever reason, and can afford CMU, than you have a difficult decision to make, and it’s not about the school, it’s about you. Make it carefully and you won’t regret it.

Who do you want to be and how to do you want to live your life? Don’t choose CMU out of fear if you actually prefer USC.