College Admission Is Not a Personality Contest. Or Is It?

Some schools over-admit qualified students and then weed out, which would strike many in the US as “unfair,” but at least when I was there a few years back, was seen by the French as fair, in that it gave more students a chance after the fact. I knew someone in a program that had a hard cap of 200 graduates but many more than that had been admitted into the program.