College list thoughts for "average excellent" S24 [$11k parent contribution, 4.0 GPA, 36 ACT]

He sounds like your niece and nephew in that he loves math and reading and politics. He really enjoys learning.

Taking advantage of the opportunities offered by elite universities such as Northwestern, Columbia, Chicago, Princeton, Stanford, etc. combined with hard work will yield a rewarding life in many respects. Yet, there will always be something missing, something sacrificed. But, that is what makes life worth living.

P.S. Some schools offer a degree in P, P, & E = Philosophy, Politics, & Economics. This may be of interest to your son. University of Pennsylvania offers this major.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophy_politics_and_economics

The wikipedia page does exist. It lists all universities around the world which offer a PP&E major.

1 Like

I tried to direct message you but couldn’t figure out how to do so. Is there a way to message you?

Like @Publisher, I’m not a nuts and bolts person with the specifics of the college process. I will say that at Northeastern (which I know is not Northwestern) that students have written the “Why this college” essay and then sent it to their admissions officer, even though it wasn’t part of the official appplication. Those essays were accepted and appear to have had some favorable results as well.

So, if there’s no option in the current prompts at Northwestern, then perhaps a supplementary essay sent directly to your son’s admissions counselor might work?

1 Like

There are two problems with this approach.

One is that these essays are usually NOT as good as the writer thinks they are.

And two- adcom’s don’t need to read more essays on “why your college is perfect for me and why I really really really want to attend”. Any additions to what they ask for should be focused on “new information about ME”, NOT “old information about you”.

I’ve had kids I’ve interviewed for Brown show up with a range of essays (neatly printed out and in a folder for my convenience). I’ve seen “Not as bad as it might have been” when a trite essay gets real right at the end, so that’s a nice surprise. But most of them fall under the category of “please don’t send these to admissions” even though the kid already has.

If the application itself is inadequate to communicate what makes a kid special- then sure. A highly edited supplement (which is why performing arts supplements exist- you cannot communicate using words the type of artistry that a person has achieved). But an extraneous essay which extols a program the adcom’s are very familiar with, describes in baroque detail why “this is a perfect fit for my needs”, explains why the program is unique?

Mmmm
 not sure this is the right strategy.

3 Likes

Yale as well. It is basically their flagship program like Oxford.

1 Like

This topic was automatically closed 180 days after the last reply. If you’d like to reply, please flag the thread for moderator attention.