Common Application Extracurricular Essay Question

<p>So, I wrote my main Common App essay about my sport and what it's taught me. I don't know whether I should write my extracurricular essay about my sport again, or write about something else.
My achievement in my particular sport is what I'm hoping will set me apart from everyone else, but I'm afraid that writing about it in two essays is kind of overkill and a bit pathetic XD</p>

<p>Any help would be greatly appreciated!</p>