CommonApp and UC app: a couple of questions.

[ClaremontMom]

1. My vote goes for the one you’ve had 2 years. But go with whoever you think will write a stronger letter. (Side note: I don’t think any of our teachers have any such limitations or “lotteries” — I find that fascinating…)

2. See this thread for options.
   
   http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-admissions/1795880-can-i-list-piano-as-an-extracurricular-activity-even-though-i-have-stopped-taking-lessons-recitals.html

I was leaning towards it could be included until I saw this argument:

Here is the disconnect for me…would practicing soccer or football with a “point” such as improving dribbling skills, passing skills etc. be an EC for a person who doesn’t play the sport on a team? I’m not sure it would be – and if not, then how would be playing piano without the formality of taking lessons or performing be one? And how would playing piano on one’s own be different from someone who likes to do positive things such as read for pleasure an hour a day which I’m guessing is not an EC. I’m not trying to be argumentative, I guess I’m just surprised that so many people here regard playing on one’'s own as an EC.

So now I think I’m convinced that shouldn’t be listed as an EC, as far as your activities list goes, but it’s certainly something that could be included in your essay (if appropriate).

4. You played on a team…sure. Of course, you should be listing your most important (important to you, not someone else) activities. If you think it’s important, list it.

5)We listed the AP Scholar awards under academic awards.