Here’s what might help. Make a spreadsheet showing the key things you like about the schools:
Job placement, study abroad, internship, location, weather, greeklife, whatever things you care about, and then rank them from 1 to 10 (for example) with 10 being the highest. Then, go through and check off which school wins in each category, add up the points, and see if one overwhelmingly outweighs the other.