Thanks people, keep it up! This list is pretty close to where she is planning to apply. The only places she hasn’t yet visited are Oberlin, Kenyon and Bates, but she plans to interview and will visit when that happens. This list includes some good bets and matches, so she thinks it is pretty well rounded. Re boy-girl ratio at Dickinson and Greek life at F & M, yes, those are def some negatives. She likes them both though. Re W& M, good point about tourist town. And yes, would love to know why kids said not to attend.