Critique my Cornell supplement

Please be brutally honest.

So far, I’m thinking I need to structure it into one or two more paragraphs, the three here seem too large - but I don’t want to lose anything and can’t figure out how to structure it better… all thoughts on anything appreciated.

<hr>

<h1>1: Describe your intellectual interests, their evolution, and what makes them exciting to you.</h1>

For me, there has always been a tendency to shy away from the hard and linear aspects of learning and to gravitate towards the more abstract sides of both academia and life. My passion with doing and accomplishing things differently started at a very young age. During my childhood, my love for creativity and curiosity was readily apparent - people applauded me for the games I made up, the pictures I drew, and the stories I wrote. Early on, one teacher in particular saw these qualities in me and strongly helped to cultivate them further. I will never forget what Mr. Gordon did in the 2nd grade: he had me stay in during part of recess and read Treasure Island out loud. It was a challenge.

I remember reading it with an ecstatic sort of endurance on my face. I would occasionally ask my teacher what a word meant, or how to pronounce it, and yet I was fully aware that it was the most difficult, yet engaging, story that I had ever read. At that age, I didn’t know that I could read something that was meant, for all intents and purposes of my young mind, for adults. Or, that such an enthralling thing could be held within the simple pages of a book. It was a white hot flash of literary and motivational enlightenment for me, and I have seeked to experience that rush of doing something you know is very hard, and then accomplishing it, again and again. I learned very young that all you have to do is merely take a chance and try. Because it’s not just the sense of accomplishment you achieve in the end that counts, it’s the experience and knowledge that comes along the way. I’m sure you get that a lot. But when experienced personally, it’s worth noting. When we finally finished the book, Mr. Gordon gave me a knowing sort of look and a very large smile. From then on, I was a risk taker.

When I think about my interests, I contemplate that reading and writing are fused joys. When I write, I can express myself in a way that math or science has never held for me. I am chiefly a creator and a traveller, not a manipulator. In writing, my creativity, views, and style can shine through in mere words on a page – these words can say, be, or mean anything I want them to. The possibilities are endless. From a farm in Alabama one second to a supernova in Alpha Centauri the next, books can create entire worlds in one Tuesday afternoon. And it is absolutely ambiguous: when I read, my mind explores someone’s elses journey. Whether it be the history of ancient Babylon to the space school in Ender’s Game, the words on the page tap into the deepest trenches of my mind and dance with the neurons. My interests are in experience and knowing. All books are suitors of both, and my deepest pleasure lays in taking their hand.

<p>I would say you are off to a good start, keep writing more, go into specifics of what you have done, and then end it off, i would say 1 body paragraph and a short conclusion should do it</p>

<p>are u sure this is within the word limit? seems a lot longer than mine and i know i pushed it.....</p>

<p>Not bad but that's twice the word limit!</p>

<p>lol its suppose to be 250 words not 500</p>

<p>be more direct...they just want to see your interests, you take a while getting to that point...still, well written...what ARE your intellectual interests? Just writing?</p>

<p>A little boring...</p>

<p>Thanks for the replies and I will be revising it. Any more comments?</p>

<p>I appreciate the effort you must have put into this, SubMerged.</p>

<p>However, you've violated Rule Number One of college essays: **It must be something that only you could have written.<a href="Thanks,%20Harry%20Bauld.">/b</a></p>

<p>Your essay isn't beyond repair, though. I'm assuming that you're majoring in English or at least something vaguely in the humanities. If you're a biochem major, it's time to scrap the essay.</p>

<p>The general message is clear; you love to read. You need personalize that and show your love for reading. The story with Mr. Gordon works well for this.</p>

<p>I'm not going to rewrite the whole essay for you. It would cease to be yours. Instead, I'll dissect some sentences to show you how you should be thinking about this. I will be harsh. Don't take it personally.</p>

<p>--</p>

<p>For me, there has always been a tendency to shy away from the hard and linear aspects of learning and to gravitate towards the more abstract sides of both academia and life.
Fluffball alert. Imagine that I'm about to fall asleep and reading my 50th essay of the day. This sentence does not engage me. I don't want to read more. If the admissions officer weren't getting paid, he would probably throw the essay on the floor and flip on the TV to watch infomercials to narrowly avoid death from boredom.</p>

<p>This sentence could be referring to anything.</p>

<p>My passion with doing and accomplishing things differently started at a very young age.
<a href="It%20should%20be%20%22passion%20for,%22%20but%20that's%20the%20least%20of%20your%20problems.">indent</a> Again, this is incredibly vague. You could still be talking about anything. Just get to the point! Or at least start telling a story or say something interesting! I'm snoozing here, man.</p>

<p>This sentence is ultimately unnecessary.[/indent]</p>

<p>During my childhood, my love for creativity and curiosity was readily apparent - people applauded me for the games I made up, the pictures I drew, and the stories I wrote.
Again, you should be showing, not telling. Whoopy, people applauded you! That's just swell.</p>

<p>You bring up many different ideas here, most of which have nothing to do with the topic of this essay--your love for reading. Creativity! Curiosity! Making up games! Drawing pictures! Writing stories! Christ man, what does this have to do with reading Treasure Island? There's a connection, but it's weak.</p>

<p>You get my point.</p>

<p>Everything in paragraph 2 can be deleted except the last two sentences. It's all cliche. Besides, your essay is twice the expected length (Not A Good Thing). You NEED to cut it. Most of paragraph 3 can be shortened and condensed.</p>

<p>Elaborate more on the Mr. Gordon story. Make it interesting.</p>

<p>Good luck. Which school in Cornell are you applying to?</p>

<p>sabnet, I love your critique. You obviously know what you're saying. I prefer absolute honesty over any bush dodging and so I thank you for the comments.</p>

<p>Here is my revision. It's much shorter, at 375 words, but I am hoping they will still find it interesting enough to finish. I know the first sentence is still pretty much up in the air, but I can't think of something that may jolt the reader out of their boredom..</p>

<p>For me, there has always been a tendency to shy away from the linear aspects of learning and to lean towards the more abstract sides of both knowledge and life. As a child, my love for creativity and curiosity was easily seen - people adored me for the games I made up, the pictures I drew, and the stories I wrote. I would sit for hours on end and flip through National Geographic. One teacher in particular saw these qualities and helped develop them further. I will never forget what Mr. Gordon did in the 2nd grade: he invited me to stay during recess and read Treasure Island out loud. It was a challenge. I hesitanty agreed.</p>

<p>As I read about parrots and wooden legs, I felt a strong sense of wonder. I had no idea that something called 'pirates' had ever existed, and I was never so captivated in my life. At that age, I also didn't know I could read something that was for, in all intents and purposes in my young mind, adults. I couldn't stop turning the pages; each one had a new experience. It was a white hot flash of literary and motivational enlightenment for me, and I have seeked to experience that rush of doing something you know is very hard, and then accomplishing it, again and again. From then on, I was a risk taker, both in learning and in life. Because I learned it's not just the sense of accomplishment achieved in the end that counts, but the things learned on the way. When we finally finished the book, Mr. Gordon gave me a knowing sort of look and a very large smile. </p>

<p>Learning and reading about experiences, stories, and knowledge, became very important for me. Not only learning about, but creating them myself - when I write, I can express myself in a way that math or science has never held. My creativity, views, and style can shine through in mere words on a page. From a farm in Alabama one second to a supernova in Andromeda the next, the possibilities are endless. My deepest pleasure lies in witnessing and expressing experience. I later returned to Mr. Gordon in the sixth grade and thanked him.</p>

<p>College of Arts and Sciences btw, and it will probably be something in the humanities, yes. :)</p>

<p>OK, I am getting help with part 1 elsewhere, and I'm revising it. But right now I would like a critique on my first draft of part two.</p>

<p>So far it sounds a little 'haughty', I will work on fixing that later - all comments appreciated on what I have now are welcome.</p>

<p>My thirst for an abstract sort of knowing, of my place in the world, and the way everything fits together, is to be put to the test. The opportunity for expansion of a wide horizon is there for me to exploit. I want to study in depth as many subjects as I can, and then see how they relate to each other. I want to work long into the night and then reflect on my progress and think to myself, “I'm beginning to understand this subject, but I still have a long way to go.” In short, I want to leave with more questions than I came in with, and with more answers to seek, but with a clear sense of purpose.</p>

<p>Unlike my high school years, I also wish to experience a core curriculum. I have experienced absolute freedom in learning, and I have seen its qualities and its shortcomings. I want to take a preset list of courses designed by those who know their worth, and then ponder why it is that I do so much work to learn those specific fields. My friend Ian, a sophomore at A&S, summed up the experience nicely: “College is hard.” I know it's hard for a reason, and I am willing to learn. Armed with the knowledge I will receive, I will decide how best to blaze my own trail. The independent major program is currently extremely appealing to me because of this. Cornell, as a community, is also very exciting due to the students having very similar attitudes regarding learning - when we get together, I know big accomplishments are waiting to happen.</p>

<p>In the end, when I leave with degree in hand, I will know that the college had developed a deep rooted awareness of both self and world in me, and that I worked very hard for it. With my new knowledge and sense of place, my path to the future will have grown much wider.</p>