Whitman has strong biology, astronomy, geology and chemistry, they are in the process of creating a comprehensive CS department but that will take a few years to fully develop… Music is good but competitive for spots in groups that regularly perform. Not as hipsterish or intense as Reed, but academically strong without being overly competitive. Kind of laid back, interesting and friendly student body. Going by dadof1’s criteria, Whitman has great science programs.
I understand from reading on CC that Saint Olaf has the music, math and CS.