<p>@lorilc and @tx5</p>
<p>Thank you for your replies! This is precisely the kind of thing I was curious about, and you both seem to know very clearly why you and your scholars wanted to (or did) choose SDSU. Concrete, specific, and filled with facts. And sometimes, yes, it just comes down to “how it feels” – in fact, I personally believe that that gut feeling/instinct is something that is highly undervalued. </p>
<p>I do recognize the extra efforts that SDSU has made on several fronts. Frankly, when I got to researching the school more deeply several months ago, I was both shocked and impressed at its impressive credentials as a world- and nationally-recognized institution, the number of subjects in which it truly thrives, the “stock” that the U.S. government itself has invested in it. This ran very contrary to what I’d remembered from the SDSU of the late 80s, and the school is to commended for all of the effort it has no doubted required to get where it is today.</p>
<p>And yes, I do think it still fights a “party school” image, although the admin has fought that in the best way possible – by raising its game so significantly that it now has the means to select only those who are much more serious about academics than they are about the next kegger. That, in my mind, is the best, longest-lasting way to change a party school rep, and SDSU is doing it very well.</p>
<p>My question was really designed to suss out those who’d done their homework and those who hadn’t. More importantly, I wanted to hear HOW they’d done it and WHY they’d chosen. I didn’t have a position to advocate or defend – I simply wanted fair and thoughtful input. You two have giving it to me, and I thank you for your time.</p>
<p>@lil – I’m sorry you’ve had to endure actual questions (gasp!) from the “judgmental and misinformed.” It sounds as if the process of enduring them has worn you down a bit. Perhaps your case – not that you should even feel compelled to present one – would be better served by less defensiveness and condescension? As I’ve said, I’m all about gut feel, but certainly any school has more to offer than “energy, enthusiasm and zest.” I’m sorry you think my perspective is “naive and frightening.” Clearly, I’ve done my homework. Clearly, I’m willing to ask honest, candid questions that aren’t easily answered. And likewise, clearly you’re defensive about your choices. I’m sorry about that!</p>