<p>Those are two very different schools. Both are obviously excellent, but one will almost always prefer one to the other. </p>
<p>Dartmouth is rural while Northwestern is suburban with America’s second city (Chicago) within very close proximity (20 minute drive or 30 minute L ride). Some people love the Dartmouth’s remote/rural location because they prefer the outdoors and prefer doing things on campus. Others would much rather have access to a major city such as Chicago. The choice here is clear and easy to make depending on the individual’s preferences.</p>
<p>Academically, if you are interested in Economics for the purpose of landing a job with an Invesment Bank on Wall Street, Dartmouth has the edge. If you are interested in Economics for the purpose of graduate school, both are roughly equal. If you just want to go to the school that offers the best Economics program possible (best minds in the field and greater course breadth and depth), Northwestern has the edge. </p>
<p>Have you visited both schools? Did you like them equally?</p>