<p>As I mentioned in an earlier post, I visited Dayton before Miami and OSU, and found myself comparing the MU and OSU campuses to UD’s. I really loved UD’s campus, facilities, and people when I visited, so I had the UD-glasses on when touring other schools. Also, these are my opinions and are obviously individual and personal, so visiting students could have completely reversed, but equally valid opinions. Your mileage may vary, etc.</p>
<p>Campus / facilities
The campus is mostly red brick and ivy with cobblestone walkways, with pockets of modern buildings that mostly fit well with the overall theme. Similar in a lot of ways to Miami, actually. But a few things set UD apart. First, while both the MU and UD campuses are based around the 100+ year old red brick buildings found throughout campus, I generally found the interiors of the beautiful old buildings to be much nicer at UD. It sounds lame, but having a clean, modern space with adequate electrical outlets, wireless connectivity (I concede that this was a bigger deal when I was visiting schools in the earlier part of this decade), decent lighting, comfortable common areas, etc can make a difference in mood and productivity, especially at this time of the year when everyone is studying for finals. This isn’t a knock on Miami; Miami really does have a beautiful campus.</p>
<p>I haven’t been in a Miami building in ~3 years, so I can’t speak to how much renovation has been done there, or how functional the buildings are now, but that was an impression I had when I visited the schools.</p>
<p>OSU had a completely different feel for me than MU and UD. I think the size was a big factor in this. Even though OSU felt smaller than I expected it would, it was just too large for me personally. Many people will obviously feel differently.</p>
<p>Let me give some background so you can get some perspective: I’m now in law school at a top-10 program at one of the top universities in the world, and honestly, I find myself missing the facilities at UD. Don’t get me wrong, we have great facilities here, but they’re not what I would expect from a school with several times as much money as UD. The seats are uncomfortable and the lighting isn’t great in most classrooms. Honestly, I never thought of myself as someone who cared about this sort of thing, but here I am. The paragraph above is influenced by my current situation, as I probably didn’t focus on facilities nearly as much until I started spending all my time in sub-par buildings ;)</p>
<p>I have one final point: Miami’s basketball arena is terrible, and UD Arena is legendary. If you’re a basketball fan, this is beyond dispute. :)</p>
<p>Surrounding area / town:</p>
<p>I also considered the surrounding area of each campus I visited. I’m not a big college-town type of person, but I love the traditional campus feel. I found that UD had a good balance between these two competing interests. The campus is sort of its own bubble about ~1-2mi south of downtown Dayton. In the middle of campus, you’d never know you were so close to an urban area, but if you want to get away there are plenty of things to do in Dayton that don’t exclusively involve college students. It’s harder to find those events in smaller college towns. This is another point that is a completely personal consideration, but I offer it for whatever it’s worth.</p>
<p>The People:
Another difference I noticed between the campuses involved the attitude of the current students/administration/faculty. When I toured UD, random students stopped our tour group to say hi to the tour guide, offer their own perspectives, tell us how much we’d love it at UD, etc. A professor walking by said hi to our tour guide. It all seemed very genuine, and not corny or planned or anything. At the other schools, I just felt like current students wanted us to get out of the way (I was in a much larger tour group at Miami/OSU than at UD, so I don’t necessarily blame them, we were totally blocking the pathways ). I also found some of the stereotypes about Miami (J Crew U) when I visited; pastel popped collars as far as the eye could see. To be fair, I may have just noticed this more because I was aware of the J Crew U/preppy reputation MU has, but I thought students at UD and OSU seemed a little less “preppy” to me. A preppy campus certainly isn’t a negative in itself, but it affected my perception of how comfortable I would feel and how well I would fit in, rightfully or wrongfully.</p>
<p>Reputation:
I’m not sure how accurate my assessment here is, since several members of my family attended Miami and now live in Cincinnati (I don’t live in Cincy), but I get the impression Miami has a better rep in Cincinnati than UD. I don’t think it’s because of any difference in quality, but rather for these factors:</p>
<p>1) There are several times as many Miami grads in Cincinnati than UD grads. Remember that there are several times as many students in the Miami University System as there are at UD. Another part of this is the fact that Cincinnati is essentially Miami’s home market, since Oxford isn’t really a market in itself, while UD has an actual city to itself. Another part is that UD, being private, has a more geographically diverse student body (I believe about 60% of apps and about 50%? of UD students come from outside OH, MU has a much more OH-focused student body). Dayton grads may disperse across the country more than Miami grads, but I have no evidence of this at all, just anecdotes.</p>
<p>2) And, Cincinnati is loyal to Xavier, its Catholic school. UD and XU are rivals, so the city is just generally more focused on Xavier news, sports, etc.</p>
<p>Outside of southern OH, I don’t think there’s any difference. I live in a major city now and I don’t think anyone is drastically more familiar with one school than the other. People are definitely more familiar with Ohio State, but that’s not surprising.</p>
<p>I have friends from UD working for big banks (err… maybe not anymore, ), in selective grad programs, Peace Corps, etc. You can do all of these things from Miami, UD, OSU, etc. For most students at any of these three schools, the name on your diploma won’t open any more doors than the other two would have. It’s the other factors, like grades, internships, recommendations, etc. that will make the difference when interviewing or applying.</p>
<p>Unfortunately, I don’t have much personal knowledge about the business schools. I think OSU’s is the best, but I really don’t have any basis for that outside of rankings… I have no new information to give - sorry!</p>
<p>So, I hope that’s a decent run-down of why I chose UD. Keep in mind that different students can have completely different impressions of schools after visiting, so it’s really important to make a trip to both schools before getting too far into the application process, in my (humble) opinion.</p>
<p>If you have any further questions, I’ll try my best to answer them. Good luck!</p>