<p>Poppymom, it sounds as if we have the same daughter! Have you considered Earlham? They have an analytical reasoning requirement that can be fulfilled by taking symbolic logic. Don’t be put off by its Quaker affiliation (my agnostic daughter initially rejected any school that had a religious affiliation), as they are not evangelical in any way and only 10% or so of the kids there are Quaker. They have a part-time (I believe) Rabbi and a Jewish Student Union. Politically liberal, with no Greek system. We visited there this past weekend and D loved it. Their mission statement on the web site has sealed the deal (for me at least!).</p>