dealing with rejection:perspective from college freshman

This post is mostly addressed to high school seniors around this time of year, and just sums up my thoughts and experiences, seeing that I’ve been talking a lot recently to high school friends about the entire ordeal.

1 for 12: One year later, looking back

Cornell
Duke
Emory
Illinois
Michigan
Notre Dame
Boston College
Johns Hopkins
University of Chicago
Northwestern
Georgetown
Williams

One acceptance, 11 denials.

That was my final college list, a high-achieving Asian male student coming from one the most competitive private schools in the area. I’m not going to list out my specific statistics, because I’ve never been fond of logistics. They were high enough to fall within the 50% range of most of these schools applicant pools, and my extracurricular activities included activities such as being editor-in-chief of an award-winning high school newspaper, heavily involvement in two musical instruments, and varsity letters/co-captain for three separate sports.

I received eight of the eleven denials within a span of four days. You can say I overshot, didn’t have enough safeties, listened to family and friends too much, didn’t follow proper CC advice. But like many, I was confident, maybe a bit overconfident, in my abilities. I knew I was a good writer, and my scores were high, so why worry right? So when the results came, I didn’t cry like some, but clearly the whole world around me seemed to change. Friends who talked about their numerous acceptances were avoided, questioning family members were ignored, and I couldn’t focus properly at all. I kept most of my feelings pent up within me, trying to maintain a steady composure throughout the day. It’s that looming, miserable feeling in your gut, the feeling of worthlessness and insecurity. The idea that you’ve been working for four years, and it has all seemingly been for naught. All those hours of community service, sports, studying, all so you could end up at some “crummy safety school”. How exactly did your friend, with lower scores, less extracurricular activities and whatnot managed to find his or her way into a top school? It must have been you’re essay or that one math class. No, maybe it’s because your counselor sent out your test scores late. Or, wait, it must have been because you’re not Native American.

The process isn’t forgiving, that’s for sure. But you’ll need to cope with it and look ahead. Looking back at how I finally did, here’s some advice:

-Browsing around CC, there are threads with claims of “my life is ruined” or “I’m just not good enough”, and certain claims even more extreme, especially around this time of year. Taking some advice my father gave me, “it’s just one small step the grand scheme of things”. The first thing you need to do is stop making yourself feel worthless, or blaming the world. You aren’t worthless, and colleges are probably not overjoyed handing out denial letters. They know you put effort into your applications, and I don’t think anyone would doubt it for a minute. I’m also pretty sure talking to any admissions officer they’ll tell you they hate reporting denials just as much as you hate receiving them. Also, great people have come from so labeled “no-name” colleges. This leads me to my next point.

-Enjoy senior year, and be positive about wherever you’re going. Senior year is probably the best year in high school, and you should enjoy it for what it’s worth. Try to find the best aspects of where you’ll be next year, find clubs you want to join, link up with fellow students. Be happy with where you’re friends have ended up. College decisions should not spoil the ends of your high school careers (and/or sever friendships), and you don’t want to be that “one dude” still upset at where he’s going after freshman year in college. You’ll find the best way to enjoy college is to get involved, and If you’re really that unhappy, transfers are always an option later. Or graduate school, which apparently is becoming an increasing trend these days.

-College will be what you make of it. Sure, you’re friend got into HYSMP, but if he doesn’t utilize the opportunities it provides he might as well have saved the additional tuition. You quickly realize once you enter the college atmosphere that everyone begins on the same footing. Those that are proactive with their education and experiences are happy and successful: those that aren’t involved and don’t put in their fair share of effort will fail and be miserable. This carries over no matter where you end up. Colleges anywhere have hosts of good professors and opportunities: it’s up to you to find them, succeed, and milk them for what they’re worth. That’s what the college experience is all about. An unofficial universal college motto should be “Work hard, play hard”.

-Ultimately, the admissions process is the butt of all jokes once you’re actually at university. You’re there, and there’s so much to do and explore that things such as your SAT or ACT scores become so trivial. In fact, my friends and I talk during lunch in the dorm halls sometimes about how competitive the process is, how we feel so sorry for our high school student friends plugging away at the next random, rhetorical essay question some committee thought up. Here, we also often shout “Go Blue!” at prospective student tour groups during game days, and always appreciate the bewildered looks on their faces. The fact is that students are generally proud of where they’re going, and this is apparent once you’re on campus. Being able to go to college is one of the greatest opportunities offered in life, and just being able to appreciate and experience it is something that you should be grateful for, even if it wasn’t #1. You’ll find out sooner or later that a lot of other people didn’t get into their top three schools. It wasn’t just you. And they’re really smart/fun too.

I’ve sat in lectures taught by outstanding experts in their fields, met wonderful people, and been challenged here in college. I’ve partied hard, but worked hard as well. The admissions process, while seemingly unfair, biased, unrelenting in one sense towards its high school applicants, taught me a valuable lesson in pragmatism and self evaluation before I left for college. So to you high school seniors, for those of you who feel that all hope is lost and you’re future is ruined just because you didn’t get into some to some top 10 school, it isn’t. Learn from the process. There are many ways to get to one place, and these four years in college are definitely ones you should treasure for what they’re worth.

Boy oh Boy did those schools miss out on not accepting you!!! You have the EXACT attitude necessary to succeed. Good for you and thanks for a post I will no doubt bookmark and save for my son.

Loved this post too. The other 11 schools definitely missed out on you, but I’m confident you’ll succeed no matter where you go!

P.S. I used to live in Ann Arbor and was at the U of M campus quite frequently. It’s a lovely place. :slight_smile:

You are obviously a well-balanced, highly motivated and positive person who should be a shining role model to all of the aspiring HS seniors on CC - smart enough to appreciate the opportunity in front of you, to take advantage of it and to succeed not only in school but in life.

I have not discerned a single shred of the “entitled” tone I read in so many student posts here - good for you for realizing how lucky you are. Michigan is an excellent school!

Congrats and thanks for sharing.

Thanks. This is what I’ve been telling myself for the last three weeks.

thanks for the advice! I can tell you are going to succeed, who needs Cornell! Best of Luck! :slight_smile:

I’ve been dwelling over my rejection for quite some time now (over a month, haha, after I thought I was officially “over it” I’m really not) and it’s been pretty hard seeing as I’ve always wanted to go to school close to home. I got accepted at only two schools, one being a safety and the other being a “safety for my top choice,” the latter of which is 5hrs away but offered me the most money and definitely provides me with more opportunities. I’m the first in my family to go to college in this country and it’s been emotionally tiring at home but I think my parents and I have come to terms with my distance and rejection, if only a little bit.

I just want to say how your post has immensely made me feel better about my rejection more than any of my friends, family, and even parents.

I cried in the process of reading this, thank you.

Thank you so much for the lovely post; your thoughts are exactly what I feel and wish I could express to everyone else. I’m so tired of hearing friends acting like college admissions are the end of the world.

I was lucky enough to have a college boyfriend who kept me grounded through this process and reminded me of this, but many of my friends didn’t and feel silly now. It’s a bit sad, really, to watch the juniors gearing up for this process as if it were the Most Important Event of their lives.

This is a great thing for people to read when rejected from colleges- you had a great idea to do this!

Thank you for your post. My DS was just like you and as he finishes his freshman year he can’t imagine himself anywhere else in the world. He has loved his college experience and has met so many different people.

Thanks for putting everything in perspective.
P.S. our next door neighbor is going to be your new kicker on the team and you stole our college coach!!

After rejection from all of my reaches, my counselor and AP teacher told me: despite your “merely” above average grades, I know you can succeed anywhere, even at Harvard. It took me a while to accept this, but now that I’m rational again, I think so too. Rejection wears off. In one year (or in my case, one month), it won’t even matter. I’m already in love with the match (actually, more like a high match, low reach) school I’ll be going to.