<p>TwinDad,
In my opinion, as a junior, she is working on her repertoire and her technique, as well as acting songs, etc. My daughter has many songs like that in her repertoire and I'd have no qualms about working on such material at all. She did not start picking out college audition songs until early fall of senior year (well, her senior year was her junior year of HS but that is another story)...basically the early fall of the year she was applying to college.</p>
<p>So, JRB, Jekyll/Hyde, Sondheim, etc. are fine to have in one's repertoire. When senior year rolls around, you can share with her and also consult with the vocal coach about overdone material or what you have learned are on "not to do" lists for BFA auditions, specifically (which isn't always the same as for regular MT auditions). I would not totally rule out JRB. There are some songs of his that people successfully audition with for college. For any MT auditions, not just BFA ones, many advise to shy away from Sondheim, and so you can share that. For one thing, his music is difficult to sight read IN GENERAL, though there may be exceptions. Jekyll and Hyde has some excellent songs and it is not as if your D can't do them except if a school like CCM says no, definitely don't do it there but other schools do not have such a "no no" list and that material is acceptable. However, many of the songs from J&H are overdone and so that is worth pointing out, particularly Someone Like You. Avoiding overdone material is wise. I don't think she has to totally rule out all the songs. Then again, if CCM is on her list, why prepare some songs from one school that you can't do at another? So, when the time comes, if she has any schools with published do not do lists, adhere to those. Also discuss avoiding overdone material, the latest "hot material", and Sondheim for college auditions. </p>
<p>However, such material is good to work on and have in one's repertoire. I know my D has sung such material before in certain situations. In fact, in three cabaret musical revues she wrote, she purposely included some songs she loves singing that she knows she can't use in auditions. So, your D should keep working on that material but also be looking for potential audition material of all types to add to her growing repertoire list. Next fall, she should focus particularly on which songs would be best for BFA auditions. There is nothing wrong with her learning Sondheim, JRB, and J&H songs at the moment, in my opinion. She should extend her knowledge of the MT repertoire....legit songs from traditional musical theater, contemporary songs, even some pop type MT songs. </p>
<p>Later, she can discuss which materials would be best for college auditions and you should surely share any "information" you have heard as you can be a resource, even though the final decisions are hers to make.</p>