Does it have negative impact if I take 3 years of 2nd language?

I am targeting for the STEM major. UM required 2 years and recommended 4 years of 2nd language. But in my senior year, I probably need to take 2 social studies and wants to drop the 2nd language. Will it hurt my application?

Why do you need to take 2 social studies senior year?

Youā€™re supposed to take 1 each of English, Math, Science, Social Science, and Foreign Language every year +1 other class that reflects your interests.

If at the end of junior year you reached Level 3 AND you plan on doubling up, you could double up in STEM, itā€™d make more sense.

What level will you have reached at the end of Jr year? What classes would you be taking senior year?

No it wonā€™t. You will have 3 years. My son dropped 4th year Mandarin for an Econ class he really wanted. If 2 is the minimum and you have 3 that is one more then the minimum. Your good.

I will reach at Spanish 4 at the end of Jr year. If I donā€™t drop it, I will take AP Spanish. In Senior, I will take 5 core courses + computer science + Econ. But I donā€™t know whether I can fit in the schedule. If I cannot, I am thinking about drop ap spanish to get AP Econ. I donā€™t know it makes sense or not.

Thank you! Just not sure the ā€˜4 years recommendedā€™ means if you take 4 yearsā€™, you get more changes for application, especially for the stem major.

If you reach Level 4 at the end of Jr year, it counts as ā€œ4 yearsā€ (1level=1 year, if you took level 1 in MS it counts, judt like Biology taken in MS ā€œcountsā€ in your HS science credits).

Therefore, you can stop at Level 4 at the end of Jr year and still have what UMich and other top universities want. šŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘

&therefore you can take AP Econ senior year without worry.

The college counselor we used said this is not true. She was an AO At an Ivy and a director of admissions at another competitive college. Middle school doesnā€™t count. They want to see four years IN HIGH SCHOOL.

If the student maxes out the language curriculum junior year and has no other options beyond, then thatā€™s fine. But a lot of schools offer a language beyond 4. If they donā€™t, then the student needs to replace foreign language with another core.

For highly selective schools, you are wise to realize that meaning the minimum is often not enough.

1 Like

Letā€™s say requirements, including foreign language requirements, for highly selective schools, arenā€™t something Iā€™m unfamiliar with.

Choosing between AP Econ and AP Spanish necessarily is a trade off, but for a future STEM major other course choices will matter much more and I canā€™t think of a situation where reaching Level 4 would derail an application. OP will need to weigh pros and cons but in his/her situation Iā€™d get an A in Spanish 4 and take AP Econ senior year.

Talk with your school advisor about this so your not confused. We donā€™t know you school but for Michigan you donā€™t need 4 years of a language. My son also wanted to take AP Econ and enjoyed it instead of a 4th year language. I would count the high school courses only BTW.

According to the CDS, one (1) year is both required and also recommended for social studies. The CDS also spells out for foreign language, 2 years required (for LSA) and 4 years are recommended.

Iā€™d ā€œlistenā€ to the CDS and take four (4) years of foreign language. I know the UCā€™s here in CA find 4 years of a foreign language ā€œdesirable.ā€ My advice is the same advice that Iā€™d gave my kids, take the 4th year of foreign language, if available.

2 Likes

ok, thank you! I also think language is a continuous learning process.

You could simply email Admissions, stating this:

Hello,

My name is ā€¦ ā€¦ and Iā€™m a Junior from ā€¦ HS (MI). I will have completed Spanish 4 at the end of this year. Do I need to take one more Foreign Language class to meet the ā€œ4 unitsā€ recommendation or is Spanish 4 considered the same as ā€œ4 unitsā€?

Thank you.

Sincerely,

ā€¦ ā€¦

(City, MI)

2 Likes

That would be at odds with what pretty much every source and every AO Iā€™ve ever talked to has said.

1 Like

Here is one who disagrees. She was an AO at Penn and director of admissions at Franklin & Marshall.

I am not disagreeing that kids get in without four full years, but I am disagreeing that itā€™s preferable:

(Paragraph 3)

Here is one who disagrees. She was an AO at Penn and director of admissions at Franklin & Marshall.

I am not disagreeing that kids get in without four full years, but I am disagreeing that itā€™s preferable:

(Paragraph 3)

Sheā€™s a consultant and author peddling her product. Not that thereā€™s anything wrong with that. Her AO experience ended 11 years ago which, in the context of admissions, is the Ice Age.

My more recent experience in dealing with AOā€™s, including Penn, is MS FL ā€œcounts.ā€ But I would add that at Penn, like many of its peers, there is a FL requirement to graduate CAS and Wharton. So students should also keep that in mind as the more FL taken in HS, the fewer FL classes (potentially) one needs in college.

3 Likes

Iā€™d say it depends.

A couple notable exceptions that Iā€™ve encountered is:

a) the Cal Poly SLO (CSU) application, where if you took, for example, Spanish 1 in 8th grade and then took Spanish 2 as a freshman in HS, not repeating Spanish 1, then the Spanish 1 in middle school is entered into the app and counts in terms of accumulating MCA (admission) points, and

b) the local elementary school district has a Spanish immersion program beginning in kindergarten. So, in the case of my Dā€™s best friend in HS, she took AP Spanish as a HS freshman and then AP Spanish Lit as a sophomore. And thatā€™s all that was offered in HS.

But I think otherwise, if beginning a foreign language in HS, I believe the top schools would find 4 years desirable.