Agreed, and I’m originally from Chicagoland. UIC has its pros (stronger academics than people believe, as well as UIC Medical Center), but it is very much a city school (its environment is, um, somewhat safe, but one does have to take caution, especially at night). Loyola should be a bit safer. I think?
Yeah, based on the OP’s original list, UIC and Loyola do not sound like backups. I mean, if the OP is from Chicago (a city mouse, not a suburban mouse) and knows how to be aware of his surroundings, then perhaps it’s a different story.
OP, don’t make this so difficult. Find an OOS public university that offers CS and where you would be happy if you had to attend. You are a high-stats applicant, so your app should trigger significant merit awards at most schools where you are a significant cut above the typical admitted student. If St. Olaf is strong in math (and you’d be happy studying math there), then it’s a good choice. Someone here on CC should be able to steer you toward public/private uni/LAC options that are strong in math/CS and could be safeties for you. I’m an English guy, so I’m no help to you.