@BookLvr Good question. I would do additional visits and wait to see if she has a clear favorite (vs. four-way tie) and ED there. I would not ED to a second or third choice. There is some information that would be useful to know, most notably what your daughter brings to the table in terms of: GPA and test scores, ECs, teacher recs, awards, overall strength of application, and whether she hits any institutional priorities for the schools. While these are competitive schools, we are not talking about 5% admission rate schools. For School A, with a 36% acceptance rate, seems that she could get in ED2 there if she is a great match for the school. Fine to ED1 there if it’s her favorite, but I would not ED1 just because it is the most likely admit according to school guidance counselor.