eating disorder and application

<p>okay so i already submitted the majority of my apps so damage done but i was wondering if anyone else had any experience with this...</p>

<p>I had anorexia for a year and a half, it started out with me wanting to run faster in track.. i wasnt trying to have like the perfect body or anything like that, it was almost an accident but anywaysss i'm over it now but it was a huge factor in my choice of major: Psychology, I want to be a therapist</p>

<p>Okay so my question is .. will this totally kill my chances because I used it for many of my supplement essays??
I wrote about how I know what its like to be crazy so I understand addiction and mental illness. I plan to use this insight to treat clients because i feel very few people "get" mental illness
I also want to work to break sterotypes because the ill tend to internalize the idea that theyre weak and stupid, and that mental illnesses are real illnesses like anything else etc etc</p>

<p>i also included a paragraph in my additional info more about like how it started, how i overcame it etc.</p>

<p>I was denied from a competitve ED school (didnt mention the eating disorder) and i feel like it will help me stand out a little since i'm so average (nonminority, good grades, blah blah) - i have a passion for it and i understand insanity on a very real level</p>

<p>straight As, APs and honors, 2200+ on SATs and all that
applying to ivies and slightly less but still competitive schools</p>

<h2>Opinions?</h2>

<p>please ignore my grammar and spelling</p>

<p>The only things I know about this issue are what I’ve seen on this forum. But I think generally it’s considered a little risky to talk about mental illness in applications - if only because so many schools are seeing a rise in mental health issues in their undergrads, so it’s something of a touchy issue.
That said, I want to say that I congratulate you on taking the risk. I hope things work out for you.
And keep this in mind: if a school rejects you because of what you told them, then you don’t want to go there anyway.
All the best.</p>

<p>Thank you so much Elanorci!</p>

<p>I reread what I wrote in my additional information and i basically said what I believe, that I would be perpetuating sterotypes about mental illness that I desperately want to break down if I did not include it in my application. When I had anorexia, I was ashamed and felt shallow and self centered but now that I am recovered and can think clearly I realize I WAS MENTALLY ILL. Anorexia is not a character flaw and I hate that people look at it as such.</p>

<p>That being said, I am still very very nervous about it. I know many people still think eating disorders are selfish/shallow/whatever and I would hate to have shot myself in the foot, letting my eating disorder hinder me once again - theres irony for ya hah</p>

<p>soooo any more opinons? i know there are other posts about this but i feel that my twist on it is unique… not oh-poor-me or look-how-much-i’ve-overcome but more i’ve been crazy and back again and know what its like so i’ve chose this major.</p>

<p>that was really long basically:</p>

<p>PLEASE REPLY THANKS hahah :)</p>

<p>this is interesting. I hope that it wont hurt you but I really dont know.</p>

<p>I’d be interested to hear what others have to say? what do other people think about anorexia and diseases like it?</p>

<p>really need opinions guys
will probably bump it a couple times
bear with me =)</p>

<p>WHAT DO YA THINK?!? will it hurt me?</p>

<p>I personally don’t think it will. I was reading a book by an admissions officer from Duke, where she read an essay the girl had written about anorexia–she wrote that she found it one of the most powerful and moving essays she’d ever read, and broke down and cried. The girl was also accepted to, and ultimately attended, Yale.</p>

<p>So, no. I don’t think writing about it will hurt you. It’s the WAY that you write about it, and from your posts, you seem to have a good grasp of language and diction. :slight_smile: Good luck in all your apps!</p>

<p>P.S. Having struggled with EDNOS myself in the past- congratulations on your recovery, and I really really admire your choice of major and future career goals :)</p>

<p>thank you and congrats yourself!</p>

<p>I reread one of my supplemental essay and I’m worried it isnt strong enough… i’m not sure if it expresses how passionate I am about this - i may have talked too much about my personal experience (weakly) and not enough about my stance on the issue</p>

<p>if i could message it to someone who would give me their very honest opinion I would be grateful :)</p>

<p>thanks</p>

<p>One of my letters of rec talks about how I struggled with depression and eventually worked my way out of it. I don’t think discussing mental illness it’s necessarily a bad thing-- it has shaped you and inevitably shows that you are a stronger person.
I’d be happy to critique your essay.</p>

<p>If I were you, I wouldnt focus on the anorexia, but I would still include it somewhere in an essay, maybe just for a paragraph of two. Focus more on what you got out of it than what it was.</p>

<p>hey guys if anyone would read my essay or offer an opinion i’d appreciate it
aka bumpPp haha</p>

<p>thanks for the PMs… anyone else??</p>

<p>You need to be careful with this one. It could go either way. I agree with the other poster who said that if you do mention it, only a few lines should address the illness, and the rest of the essay should focus on over coming it, and what great things you have done and what you want your future to be. </p>

<p>The first year of college can be very stressful. Some students have problems adjusting. Some admission reps might (stress “might”) read your essay and view you as a potential risk. This is the risk you take with writing on this topic. </p>

<p>My suggestion is write it the way you want - focus on everything positive (don’t use words like “crazy” or “insanity” - stick with clinical terms). Then have someone you trust read it for feedback. If you still have a therapist, have them read it. </p>

<p>Keep in mind that there are many ideas for good essays.</p>

<p>thanks for the response…</p>

<p>i’ve send the majority of my apps in already WITH words like crazy and insanity
… the title is actually “crazy”</p>

<p>because i’m trying to talk about it in raw terms, for what it really is, not how i overcame “an illness” in general, which I think clinical terms would be better</p>

<p>i had a ton of essay topic ideas but chose this - do you mind if I PM you my essay to get your opinion?</p>

<p>okay i’ve debated this but its making me really nervous i’m just going to post my essay, i dont think anyone will copy it or anything, right? this is for Princeton but i sent smiliar essays to a bunch of other schools:</p>

<p>Crazy</p>

<p>“Those who are crazy enough to think they can change the world, usually do.”
-Steve Jobs</p>

<pre><code> Sitting here writing this, I think of you, the admissions officer, reading my application. I think of you looking at my grades, recommendations, extracurricular activities, race, gender, and location, and giving a half-hearted sigh as you turn to this essay as if to say, “another one of these.” If I had been applying a couple years ago, I would have absolutely agreed with you; I would have been a perfectly adequate candidate but nothing special, nothing different. Today, however, I can tell you with confidence that I am more than adequate, that I can offer your school, Princeton University, diversity in a way that goes beyond skin color and gender.

My high school career began just like any other, but by sophomore year, I wanted something more challenging that I could work on and excel at. Running for the track team answered the call. I threw myself wholly and completely into training and what started as a hobby, became an obsession. I began running at least ten miles a day, going for late night jogs after practice in the wind, freezing rain, and snow. No one could deter me from doing whatever it took to get my time down just a few more seconds, even though it was obviously wearing on me. I thrived on the test of running just one more mile, of pushing the pace, and myself, to the limit. Eating was an integral part of my training and just like everything else, it became an obsession. Somewhere in my extensive reading on running, I had seen that a person could improve their times by eating healthier and possibly even losing some weight, less to carry equating to a faster run. I took this to heart and started eating less and less while at the same time working out more and more. Somehow, I did not see how this could possibly develop into a problem. Only three months after I revamped my training regime, I was diagnosed with anorexia nervosa, a huge wakeup call, and though I am fine now, the experience has left me forever changed in how I look at the world and myself.

The prevalence of mental disorders is surprisingly high with one in four adults suffering from a diagnosable condition. Though this rate is huge, higher than cancer, the diseases are rarely even heard of, swept under the rug like a dirty little secret, something worthy of concealment and shame. This stems from an erroneous general attitude towards mental illness, that since the disorders usually manifest solely through behaviors, they are a choice rather than a disease, a mark of personal weakness and incompetence. This falsehood is especially frustrating because the ill tend to internalize these ideas that they are somehow less than because they were unlucky enough to develop a disorder and now cannot “just snap out of it.” The judgment is unnecessary as well as cruel, similar to the criticism faced by individuals enduring poverty, homelessness, and addiction. These people do not need condemnation, but rather empathy and kindness to help them through recovery.

Though my experience with mental illness was difficult to say the least, I know I would not take it back for anything if given the chance. It allowed me rare insight into a completely different world and helped me to realize that I wanted to study Psychology to become a therapist and help others to sift through the complexities of their minds and improve their lives. I know what it is like to feel crazy and to second-guess your own thoughts, and I plan to utilize this understanding to treat others with utmost respect and empathy. However while I have this foundation, I appreciate the fact that I will need a great deal of education and guidance before I can accomplish this dream. I believe Princeton University has the ideal atmosphere, commitment to academic excellence, and approach to learning to help me realize my potential to help others and change misconceptions about mental disorders. I am confident that I will achieve this goal with passion and humor, no matter what challenges I may face, because I have gone to the brink of insanity and back and am now just crazy enough to change the world… so watch out.
</code></pre>

<p>acsdszdccdfv</p>

<p>i really like your essay, its very honest and you can tell you wrote it from the heart!
all i have to say is that, a very good friend of mine also dealt with anorexia during her 11th grade year of high school, she was forced to take the year off and move to a small school since being able to catch up in her previous school would have been impossible, basically after she beat anorexia she decided that she would buckle down and do tons of summer school to catch herself up, and she did. she improved improved her grades and her SAT scores though werent ivy status, were very respectable!!
I know she wrote about her experiences with anorexia in her college essays ( she is now a freshman in college) and she got into TOP schools to break it down a little.
she was a female, not a minority, had a 4.4 gpa and about an 1850 on the SAT.
she didnt stand out significantly, she really didnt even have a team or sport or club she was part of! but she really wrote honestly and from the heart and was able to get into some REALLY great schools and is at a top university right now. so i say, if you feel this essay is form the heart and you are confident in it, then go for it!</p>

<p>Hi callme, it sounds like you really want some feedback! I think writing an essay about any kind of mental illness is risky, because adcoms probably want to guard against the possibility of having students commit suicide or other acts of violence on campus. That being said, I don’t think you sound “crazy” in your essay - perhaps because you didn’t delve deeply into your thoughts and feelings when the anorexia had its grip on you. </p>

<p>I like how you explain about the prevalence of mental disorders and the stigma associated with them, and how your experiences caused you to want to study psychology to help others similarly afflicted. </p>

<p>I also liked the Steve Jobs quote at the beginning and the tie-in at the end (but I would have left off the “so watch out”.) Also, I probably would have not used the word “insanity”, but instead changed it to “desperation” or something.</p>

<p>And just for CC protocol’s sake, I should mention that it’s not a good idea to post your essay, because people could actually copy (parts of) it. </p>

<p>Good luck with your applications and be sure to go to a college environment where you can remain healthy. You might want to check, for example, if your future college has an eating disorders support group, or you might want to start one when you get there.</p>

<p>I’m not an admission rep; just want to make that clear. </p>

<p>However, I think your essay is excellent. Clearly, you are intelligent and well spoken. </p>

<p>The only thingt that gives me pause is that you state you are “fine now” - there isn’t any acknowledgement that this may be something that you have to be aware of and watch for warning signs of in the future. I think this is true of most psychiatric issues - many of them are sort of like illnessness that are in remission, but not entirely cured. It doesn’t mean that you will ever have a relaps, but you are more likely not to if you remember that the tendency is there. You may already be aware of this, but that didn’t come through in the essay. It could, however, come through in an interview if asked about it in the future. </p>

<p>Regardless of what school you go to , you will do very well. It’s not so much the school as the person attending. We create our own success. If you are denied admission, it won’t be a reflection of your ability (or even the subject of your essay) - sometimes things just “are”. </p>

<p>Excellent essay; you should feel very proud of it. Good luck.</p>

<p>thank you so much! for both the critque and encouragement. I appreciate the fact that this type of disease is never entirely cured … as frustrating as that is. haha</p>

<p>I’m trying to make peace that I have put myself out there to the fullest extent and for colleges, it will be take it or leave it in my case. I was just really worried that I had put myself all out there in a poorly written, poorly expressed way (which would be the worst thing I could do in my opinon). </p>

<p>Thank you for all who responded and I would of course still appreciate anyone else who has anything to offer :)</p>

<p>I hate to weigh in negatively here because the OP has already applied, already taken the risk. But many are reading this who will have to make a future decision on whether to take this approach.</p>

<p>My advice? Don’t. Anorexia, like depression and many other mental disorders, recurs more often than not. Like alcoholism, for most it’s a life long struggle, not something cured in a short while. </p>

<p>Colleges will protect themselves by avoiding potential problems. </p>

<p>A college essay, in the vast majority of cases, should focus on positives. While someone who suffers a mental illness may gain some empathy, others gain empathy in many ways. Adcom are not mental health professionals. They can not parse who is really better, what the future holds or what all the issues are. Part of their job in creating a class is to yield one with a high graduation rate and as few problems as possible.</p>