Essay Critique

Hey, i’ve been working on my essay which would be going to a lot of top schools. I was hoping I could get some help/suggestions from the people on this board. Some of my concerns are just the overall content. There are probably some grammar problems. Also there is sort of a shift in the second to last paragraph, that I am wondering would be better saved for the end. I kind of just wanted it to be in the stream of events which is why I did it this way. Also its 652 words, so if you can find way to shorten it, that’d help.

<pre><code>My heart filled with fear as I felt the leash go limp. Slowly I turned to confirm my suspicions, and as I had imagined, my dog had managed to escape from her harness. She sat, almost grimacing at my error, aware that I had inadvertently freed her. As I moved ever so slowly towards the animal, hoping she had not discovered my mistake, she darted into the unforgiving woods. My heart sank, but even so I dashed into the woods. If I could catch her early, my unsuspecting parents would never know. Hence, the arduous hunt began.

Claiming the role of hunter, I relentlessly kept my eye on my prey as we jetted through the woods. Only moments before my dad had bestowed upon me the responsibility of walking the dog for the first time. “David” he lectured, “always remember to put the leash through both her chain and harness”. Previously I had dismissed such instructions as frivolous, seeing myself as more than capable to walk the dog down the street without any complications. Ashamed of my own irresponsibility, and afraid of their disappointment, I couldn’t go back to the house.

Weaving through trees and dodging logs, I fell farther and farther behind. The loud thumps of my feet hitting the ground. The smell of perspiration dripping down my forehead. I was having trouble keeping up with her small, maneuverable body as I fought my way through brush. Hearing a tare, I looked down, only to see a gaping hole in my recently purchased Nike T-shirt. I couldn’t help but feel deserving. The chase in the woods eventually brought me to a stagnant stream. Finding no easy passage, I plunged into the stream. Unfortunately, the dog had eluded me in the commotion, and I was left there, dripping wet, torn shirt, and exhausted. Eventually I emerged in a neighborhood I had never seen before. My embarrassment that a place so close could seem so foreign to me was interrupted by my parents calling. They correctly reasoned dog walks do not take nearly this long. I have always been one to try to fix my mistakes before seeking my parents aid.

I regrettably slumped backed to the house, eyes staring down at my soaked feet to avoid contact with my parents. No words were exchanged, but I hoped my disheveled appearance was of some value. I changed into more seasoned clothes, and headed out. I refused to let their hard earned trust evaporate.

What had started out as a battle with man’s best friend, transformed into an illuminating event. My narcissistic approach to this simple task was the origin of the disastrous situation. This mere dog search contained parallels in my own life as a team captain and class president. I realized that being a leader does not guarantee that my way will always be the right way. On the contrary, I must listen to what more experienced people have to say, and take an open minded approach to everything I do. Little did I know this event is just one of a series of events that would help expand my mind to be better suited to the diversity of college life. Whether tutoring a student the night before a big exam, or delivering the motivating speech before a game, I have a responsibility as a leader to lead by example and listen to the concerns and suggestions of my peers. Over the years I have found much gratification in seeing my goals, and the goals of those I lead, both intertwined, come to fruition.
</code></pre>

Darkness was setting in. Finally, a glimmer of hope came in the form of jingles from her chain. I approached her like a cat ready to pounce. By now the beast was fatigued, and I was filled with adrenaline. Before long she capitulated. I proudly carried my spoils back, glowing at my triumph over both beast and nature.

<p>sry, the question was about an event and its influence.</p>

<p>Before I trouble myself with editing, I'll just say that the concept is weak and the execution is par. The topic of talking about losing your dog for a couple of brief hours is interesting, but it becomes absolutely irrelevant with the direction you chose for the remainder of the essay. There is not a real connection between taking responsibility for walking the dog for one day and talking about your leadership experiences; in fact, it seems a bit forced, like you wanted to talk about the dog story but you felt your essay had to show "character" so you decided to add it in somewhere along the long. There are several examples of awkward vocabulary- writing in the vernacular is completely fine. Unquestionably, the weakest part of the essay is the second-to-the-last paragraph. Not only is the content remarkably cliche, but you are describing what you learned as opposed to showing it through your essay. To demonstrate:</p>

<p>"I realized that being a leader does not guarantee that my way will always be the right way. On the contrary, I must listen to what more experienced people have to say, and take an open minded approach to everything I do."</p>

<p>You don't tell the admissions officials that you have to take an 'open-minded approach' to everything that you do, you show it by giving examples. Anybody can write that sentence, that sentence can be found in any essay, it can be used in any essay- you must attempt to write something that is both meaningful and unique. The situation itself, be it walking across Antarctica or walking a dog, does not have to be inherently different from all other topics, but what you derive from it must show a perspective unlike any other and personal to you (and you only!). I'd suggest one of three things: (1) if you insist on using this story, reevaluate what the experience meant to you- the lessons you supposedly arrived at are not consistent with the story; (2) choose another topic that shows what you've learned from your leadership positions; (3) write a totally new essay. If you really, truly believe that this essay is the "right one," then I'll be glad to help you revise it. Best of luck,</p>

<p>TTG</p>

<p>"My narcissistic approach to this simple task was the origin of the disastrous situation."</p>

<p>I thought this was the link. I had originally not listened to my dad's suggestions believing my way was the right way, but seeing the disastrous results helped me improve upon by narrow mindedness.</p>

<p>Oh no, I got that, but I still intend there's no "real connection." It's a stretch, at best, considering this is how your essay goes when simplified:</p>

<p>Parents told me to go walk the dog and to be careful; I said "don't worry about it"; I lose dog; I'm ashamed and learned my lesson; I now understand (apparently you hadn't before the dog episode) that I have to listen to other persons beside myself, and I'll talk about unrelated topics such as captainship and being student body president; dog returns and I am relieved.</p>

<p>At any rate, I'm banking on the fact that you'll find something else to defend and refute the claim that your essay is not absolutely wonderful, great, or any other superlatives you are used to. Whether you take the advice given or not, that's not for me to decide, but in the end it won't make your essay any better. I still think that the essay is very weak for many reasons beyond the technical writing and content, themselves. I'm still more than willing to read any revisions you may make to this essay and will be happy to read any other essays you may throw at me (that is, unless you continue to try to defend this essay... I don't know, I suppose it reminds me of posters who say "no, you are wrong" in 'what are my chances' threads <em>shrug</em>). Best of luck,</p>

<p>TTG</p>

<p>"At any rate, I'm banking on the fact that you'll find something else to defend and refute the claim that your essay is not absolutely wonderful, great, or any other superlatives you are used to."</p>

<p>Okay theres no need to be rude and insult me. I was just trying to give you my side of the essay, there were no attacks on you and I am going to take your advice and quite possibly choose a new topic altogether.</p>