<p>How important is it to have examples from literature or history? I ask, in part, because this seems easier with some of the prompts from the recent years than others. </p>
<p>Reading examples from the CollegeBoard (the official blue book and the website), it seems that you can score a 12/12 with no examples from history or literature if the essay is very well written and the examples are very fitting. The personal examples might be from one's life or from someone else's (akin to a brief biographical description).</p>
<p>However, reading this website, it sounds like you are absolutely doomed if you do not have 3 examples from literature and/or history. That maybe, just maybe you could do 1 example that is not history and/or literature and still come out with a decent score. But without history and/or literature examples, we are looking at an 8 or 9 tops, but probably something below a 7. </p>
<p>I do agree that all else equal that 3 different examples from history would probably read better than 3 examples all about one's brother, or even one for three different family members. I would imagine that with three scholarly examples, the readers might be more lenient with other aspects of the essay, such as the reader's vocabulary. </p>
<p>But from the rubric, I do not see anywhere it implies that a 12/12 (or a 6 point score per reader) requires 3 history or literature examples. </p>
<p>I just wanted to open this topic up for discussion. Are the examples on the webpage and in the blue book absolutely misleading?</p>