Freshman grades and Ivy advice

Ok…I’ll flip,this around. Anyone else have a top 5% student with almost all A’s in HS who didn’t apply to,ANY Ivy or equivalent schools?

And this same student had a 4.0 GPA in 9th grade.

What school has NHS inductees at the end of 9th grade? My kid was NHS as well…and did all the required community service…which she would have done anyway. She didn’t even put NHS on her applications.