Gap Year Before College: A User Review

<p>Gap years are a lot more popular than they were in our day. But because many of us parents don't have personal experience with them, if our kids want to take a year between high school and college, we tend to have a lot of questions, and they tend to have questions that we can't answer. In case anyone is interested, here's a summary of our family's experience with our daughter's year abroad before college.</p>

<p>SUMMARY: She did go abroad; she didn't do City Year, or take a year to earn money for college, or to decompress, or to learn more about herself (explicitly, I mean) before college. She did apply to college her senior year, choose one of the colleges she'd been admitted to, and then defer her enrollment for a year. (*NOTE: I cannot recommend this approach highly enough. **It would be *much more complicated to apply to college for abroad, and I would avoid that hassle if at all possible.) She isn't back quite yet. She'll return to the States in about 10 days (and then be home less than a week before she jets off to be a summer camp counselor 750 miles from home!).</p>

<p>THE GOOD: Our daughter really has become more competent. She gets around cities on buses; she gets herself back and forth between cities; she goes into shops and deals with shopkeepers in the local language (a language in which she had some basic skill before she left). And after a close call, she now watches the balance in her bank account.</p>

<p>She has come to tolerate her parents' ongoing involvement in her life better. When she was leaving, she didn't want us to have access to her U.S. bank accounts, her college portal, etc. We submitted to her that we weren't just trying to be busybodies. We said that when adults go abroad for a year (for business, with the armed forces, whatever), they often choose somebody in the U.S. to act as their agent and handle their domestic business for them. All we wanted was to serve as her agents. She acquiesced unhappily; she is now glad she agreed.</p>

<p>We have made some progress ourselves in trying to meddle only in the big things, and let the smaller stuff go. We tend to micromanage. We always have. We still do, but less so. In a way, we needed her to take a gap year, so we could develop some skills in the area of butting the heck out.</p>

<p>She has grown weary of 18-year-olds who are out of their parents' direct supervision and control for the first time. She finds that "reveling in my newfound freedom" stuff a little tiresome. I hope she still will next year, when she has midterms to take, papers to write, etc. I hope this will smooth out some of the ups and downs of her first year of college.</p>

<p>Skype, international calling cards, cell phones and email. We really are in touch with her about as much as we need to be--and more than when she's off all summer being a camp counselor.</p>

<p>THE BAD: It's expensive. What costs more than four years' worth of college tuition? Five years' worth of college tuition. A gap year actually is less than the COA at a private college, but this program isn't very far off from the cost of a year at our state flagship for a state resident who lives on campus.</p>

<p>The return to college hasn't been trouble-free. Her college was happy to grant her a year's deferment so she could go on a gap year. They really do seem to like the idea of kids taking a year before they're freshmen. But now they're understandably preoccupied with the kids whom they've just admitted (and then wooed to attend this college instead of some other one); sometimes the handful of gap-year kids kind of disappear from this institution's radar screen. And there's a lot to be done for next fall: course selection and registration, housing, scheduling orientation, and placement testing, to name a few. Some of these things can be done online. That's OK when your kid has good Internet access, which ours hasn't always. So she and I have both had to noodge the university occasionally to remind them that she needs to be kept up to speed on tasks and deadlines. And there have been glitches. For instance, she completed some forms last year, before her deferment came through, that really need to be revised before 2012-13, but because they're shown as complete at her portal, she can't access them. Another example: her college determines housing priority by the date you pay your deposit. She paid her deposit in April 2011--before even the Early Decision kids--but somebody lost track of that information. Instead of first in line, they put her last. When I finally got in touch with the director of on-campus housing, he graciously fixed that very quickly. But it took me several triess to get to him. And I have to make the phone calls because I'm not calling internationally from seven time zones away. Occasionally when I call, there is some initial consternation on their part that my daughter's father is trying to handle her business for her, but that usually vanishes when I explain the situation. People are usually helpful; I just think we might have placed more calls to the university than the average family has. And these are the hassles that make me shudder at the thought of applying to college during a gap year.</p>

<p>She did go to an emergency room for an allergic reaction to peanuts while she was away. That was tense for us. But we all survived.</p>

<p>OVERALL ASSESSMENT: Totally worth it for this kid and this family. We've fallen a little bit out of love with the particular program she's on (It's small; you're probably not considering it for your teenager.), but if we had it to do again, we'd absolutely send her on a gap year.</p>

<p>Both daughter have birthdays at end of May. They also both have learning challenges that make them young for their age. They both took a year off.</p>

<p>Oldest did one year with CityYear, working with challenged populations, in our own city.
It was eye opening for her I’m sure. We are blue collar, but live in a nice if working class neighborhood ( then again Seattle is a working class city), but she had always attended private schools, the kind that gave us 5 figures in aid to send her. She worked with students; taught inner city high school kids, computer skills and homeless elementary school kids, everything, and although her undergrad is in biology, she is receiving her MIT next month.</p>

<p>Youngest didn’t quite take a year off, she had to work two retail jobs for half of the year in order to save enough money to have a volunteer vacation for the other half.
Senior year of high school ( inner city public) she participated in a program which taught kids to repair and refurbish computers and peripherals, with the culminating goal to take the computers and install them in a village in a developing country. The kids raised the money and made all the preparations for the trip. Each staff member ( which my daughter was although it was also a class), was responsible for an aspect. It made a huge impression on her, previously her travel had been domestic ( although always with school), so going to a village in Africa that didn’t have easy water access, was eyeopening. ( that wasnt where they installed the computers, but one of the teacher chaperones is also a tribal chief of a small village and one of the goals of the trip was also to help this village). That influenced her to go to an area for her gap year that was “rustic”.
As opposed to say Paris, France, like the children of my friends do. ( however, D also brought me back clothes!) :wink:
Living & working in rural India wasn’t so expensive, airfare was the largest expense.
Except for the weeks when we didn’t have personal contact with her because she was traveling in areas without cell service :eek:!, I would highly recommend some time off before college.</p>

<p>She really loved it</p>

<p>Sikorsky, was your D’s progam primarily traveling or volunteering? What was the problem with her particular program, so that I know what to avoid? </p>

<p>Thanks for the info on college details that need to be handled upon return.</p>

<p>I thought it would have been great for my S. He’s young – a late September birthday. He wouldn’t hear of it. Oh well. We’re not in the driver’s seat.</p>

<p>That was a great overview, sikorsky— thanks!</p>

<p>Toledo, her program was supposed to be…hmm…a mix of educational (but not for college credit), religious, and cultural. Depending on how you structured your gap year, the learning could be all experiential, or partly experiential and partly didactic. The experiential learning included an element of volunteerism, which was a great experience for our daughter. The problems we had stem mostly from the small size of the program, I think. It had a handful of Americans together with a number of Europeans and some participants from the southern hemisphere (who attend something like February to November, instead of October to June like the northern hemisphere kids). The North American office of this program isn’t very well run, and the religious component of the program didn’t quite deliver what it suggested it would.</p>

<p>Emeraldkity4, those sound like really rewarding experiences for both your daughters!</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I got hit by this too when I took a gap year (actually, I took two - an intended gap year, and then a forced one due to financial issues). In my case, class registration took place before health immunization forms were due, but because I hadn’t submitted health immunization forms from the year before since I hadn’t enrolled, there was a block on my student account and I couldn’t register for classes. To their credit, they fixed it quickly.</p>

<p>Depending on the school, departments may not talk to each other and you can sometimes encounter surprising problems - the bursar didn’t tell anyone that I had an extension on my bill, and just before I got on the plane to go to school I got a barrage of emails: the registrar told me I might be dropped from classes, housing told me I might be evicted, and the international students’ office told me I might lose my visa status, and therefore be illegal. Yikes!</p>

<p>Now that I’m a student, I’m still getting emails for Class of 2013 and Class of 2014, which I find funny.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Just wait. I’m sure they’ll invite you to contribute to both classes’ fundraising efforts, too.</p>

<p>Is it just my imagination, or is it that a lot of “gap year” threads are from students who got “shut out” in the admissions process, rather than those who planned for it earlier on?</p>

<p>Also, it does seem like a luxury for a student to do anything other than work (or enter military service) and/or go to community college and plan to transfer if s/he got “shut out” in the admissions process (including financially “shut out” due to insufficient financial aid). A cost equivalent to an extra year of college without financial aid is unlikely to be affordable to any but the wealthiest families.</p>

<p>I want to take a gap life :)</p>

<p>How do you figure a gap year costs equlivalent to a year of college?
As I stated earlier, oldest did CityYear.
CityYear pays a living stipend.
It also earns the participant an educational award to be applied to tuition or education loans at the end of their year of service.
Additionally, participating in CityYear may have tipped the scales in favor of D being admitted to a reach private school that met 100% of need but was needawarefor admission.</p>

<p>Her sisters program did cost money. Which was why she worked two jobs to save money for airfare and her living expenses. True her experience was " only" fiveish months, and because she had to earn the money her airfare was more expensive than if she had been able to book it earlier, but the cost wasn’t equivalent to an extra year of college. ( or even half as much)</p>

<p>Ek, how did your daughter like city year? I am going to do a gap year but can’t pay for anything, so it will need to have a living stipend. I would love if you could elaborate :slight_smile: </p>

<p>Ucbalumnus, I think it depends on the student… If you look at the ivies they generally have 50-60 incoming students who choose to take gap years (not counting Harvard z listers). These kids were not “shut out,” and there are many other students who defer, obviously it’s not just at ivies. Many gap years are spent volunteering, working, or doing other activities that do not cost money. Or, like EK’s daughter, they work to save money then pay for the trip themselves. A gap year is certainly not for only rich students.</p>

<p>Sikorsky, this is hugely informative. I really want my S13 to apply, defer, and take a gap year bc I think he needs the maturity, the perspective, and the break from academia. We’ve looked into programs that cover costs but he is resistant to the idea (even though he’s the first to admit that he is burnt out). Did your daughter come up with the idea on her own or did you? Ek, same to you–how did you guys arrive at the decision? And what did you think of City Year?</p>

<p>Emerald: I should have said that this gap year, 9 months abroad, was expensive. But I’m sure you’re right that it can cost less. Fair point.</p>

<p>MomofNEA: we suggested it to her. She was chronologically young for her class and not as self-reliant as we’d have liked. We also thought a year before college might give her some time to make some typical 18-year-old’s errors before she got to college. She wanted a chance to learn the language. We all wanted it, but for different reasons.</p>

<p>My d started thinking about a gap year winter qtr. she had applied to four 4yr schools and was admitted to all, but was a little burnt out at thinking about continuing on the academic treadmill. Some of her friends who were a year older were doing programs through LeapNow, an organization that put together packages according to your interests.
A wee bit out of our price range.
CityYear is just one of the Americorps
Programs, but it was undergoing a big push, and was local, so she decided to look into it after she heard from the one program that turned her down. ( graphic design @ SCCC.)
It probably just was getting started, it was in 2000.
Her sister also did the Americorps young heroes program at the same time.</p>

<p>Oh my goodness… Leap year is $34k. </p>

<p>The cityyear website appears to be down, I guess I’ll check again in a few weeks.</p>

<p>A million years ago I did a gap year in France. I lived with a French family and studied French at a language institute. The second half of the year I audited classes at the local university.</p>

<p>The Good
I emerged fluent in French. I became a little less driven. I learned to love architecture. Signing up for classes was not an issue because Harvard doesn’t make you register for them until two weeks into the term. </p>

<p>The Bad
The only bad I can think of is that my five year reunions from both high school and college were invariably scheduled for exactly the same weekend. It was not cheap. (I think you could get a similar benefit from being an au pair however.)</p>

<p>I have several friends whose kids have spent half the year doing language programs in Costa Rica, and half doing NOLs and are also very happy with the results.</p>

<p>Harvard BTW was new to the gap year business when I did it, but they did not make any difficulties. They now encourage it saying that in their experience students who take a gap year do better on average in college than those who don’t.</p>

<p>I am glad that some kids find something to do exciting between high school and college, but taking a year off can also mean working for a year and taking a break before starting formalized education again. I do think on some level it’s important to acknowledge that some kids would do well to have another year of maturation before heading off to college and the personal growth can come from many things and doesn’t need to cost $30,000.</p>

<p>The Americorps site is working.
[url=&lt;a href=“http://www.americorps.gov/]AmeriCorps[/url”&gt;http://www.americorps.gov/]AmeriCorps[/url</a>]
Youngest was accepted into NCCC which sounds like a great program.
It is even more team based than the other programs as you Are trained at one of five campuses, then travel for ten months assisting people in you assigned region,sleeping in church basements and the like.
It sounded a little intense & I was concerned as D has some spectrumy quirks that really react better with her own space. One of her High school teachers talked her out of it, using her sisters experience to convince her. ( her sister didn’t complete the program)</p>

<p>So D decided to go to a challenged region , 8000+ miles away, where they didn’t speak English and everything was unfamiliar instead.
So reassured.</p>

<p>DD is halfway through a gap quad. She had planned to retire from her ice dance career after high school and applied to colleges. Long story short, she was presented with an amazing opportunity to train with a new coach and skate with a new partner and is now training to qualify for the Olympics in 2014 (no guarantees, but Lahr likelihood is good). She has fortunately been able to negotiate a deferral from her college through 2014, but can matriculate earlier should her plans fall through.</p>

<p>I agree with posters who recommend that students apply to colleges senior year while the momentum is there and then negotiate a deferral–it’s also comforting to know there’s an acceptance to fall back on. I also recommend that if the gap year is non-academic in nature that the young person do something to maintain at least basic study skills. DD is still meeting weekly with her old Latin tutor, is working with a Russian tutor, and is keeping her French up to speed on her own. She’s also planning to work her way through a writing curriculum starting in the fall, so she won’t be rusty when she finally gets to school. (DD was home schooled, so self-study is a good option, but there are lots of on-line and cc classes to choose from.)</p>

<p>DD still lives at home, which is working well for us, both financially and as a family. It’s alittle different from when she was younger, and required a few adjustments, but all of us are happy to have the extra time together.</p>