<p>I think I can see why this might happen in this instance; there is only one teacher on this instrument, and this teacher is the one who would be hearing the audition and making the call. So, essentially, the teacher has indicated he or she has already heard the audition and doesn’t see the point in holding another one. </p>
<p>That said, I also remember what SpiritManager describes; someone was accepted by the studio, but not the school. Definitely scope this out more. Every school and teacher is different. This type of thing is not that common an occurence, but perhaps for this particular teacher at this school, it is.</p>
<p>woodwinds- I think the key words in your quotes from your D’s current teacher (and your assessment of your brother) are “years ago”. I’m sure that it happened to then just as you say, but its not common practice now. There are so many kids, really good ones with tons of experience, who are auditioning , that frankly, schools would be foolish to commit to anyone until they hear they whole applicant pool. There are some school with rolling admissions, but the top conservatories don’t operate that way.
Your D is very talented and also very wise since it seems like everyone is gabbing on social media without a second thought these days. I’m anxious to see her acceptance list next spring- it will be amazing, I’m sure!</p>
<p>The only person who can address your concerns is the professor in question. If this is your daughter’s first choice, take these concerns to him. He obviously wants her there so he will gladly do whatever he can to make sure it happens. Ask him straight up about scholarships, admissions, and getting something in writing. </p>
<p>It would be really unusual for your daughter to be accepted to his studio and then be rejected at a CONSERVATORY. (Totally different deal at a university SOM.) Take your concerns to him. If you do not get satisfactory answers, I assume your daughter will audition with everyone else. If you are not 100%, lock down sure about what he can offer, go through the process. You are in a great position. Having just gone through this with a second kid, I know that it’s easy to play all of these “what if” scenarios in your head. Don’t make it more complicated than it has to be.</p>