<p>I am not sure about the weighted question..probably some of the regulars know. But as a Virginia resident, it is awful to have a student like that in-state rejected. I can't guess why. I do know UVa weighs essays very heavily. But in this case..you would think his essays were good enough to interest Harvard? so who knows
My only message to you is don't sell so called Match Schools short...many of them are also glamorous, well funded places that make great impacts on their communities and also deserve a loyal following of alum and new students each year..one of the things we are wealthy In America with is fine universities. And doing quite well at a Match school can often lead to graduate study at a Reach some day.</p>