<p>In:
William & Mary
NYU (oddball choice compared to the other schools on your list. I would personally have Boston College and Tufts on your list, too).</p>
<p>Reaches:
Everything else (Chicago is low reach, the others are reasonable reaches).</p>
<p>Try some better state flagships, like UCLA, UC Berkeley, Uva, UMich, and UNC-Chapel Hill. They tend to look at statistics more than EC. Also try some liberal arts colleges if you are confident in you essay writing skills.</p>