<p>I've posted on this before, but I have 2 problems with the Montauk and Klein book.
First, it is so detailed on so many issues that it is difficult for the reader to figure out what is important and what isn't. Some things for which there are very long chapters aren't important at all.
The second is that it relies so heavily on sitting elite college admissions officers, that it is virtually a mouthpiece for them. It is candid to the point that these people can be. No more useful than going to a panel discussion of admissions officers, with a Q & A session following.
I have to say that I feel I have gotten the best info from the "tell all" books by now outsiders.
I know I disagree with my good friend tokenadult on this.</p>
<p>A "tell-all book"? Do you mean one like the x secrets parents/colleges never told u? I was always a little skeptical of them, but I did read one and it was helpful</p>