ACT 1: E-32; M-36; R-30; S-32 W-8/12 C: 33 (32.5)
ACT 2: E-35; M-35; R-28; S-34 W -Pending C: 33 (33.25)
Which one should i use for schools that do not superscore?
If I were you, I would send in your second score. But definitely send in both scores to all of your colleges even if they don’t superscore; especially if your second ACT writing score is lower than your first.
And anyway, colleges are caring less and less about your ACT/SAT scores. They’re more interested in your essay, rec letters, and extracurriculars, so I wouldn’t get too hung up on your score and adjust your focus to other areas of your application!