Help. Essay #2 is exactly my personal statement

Same as title. My personal statement talked about the exact topic asked in prompt #2.
What should I do?
I can’t rewrite the same things all over again.

I meant essay #1. I got confused because of the “what activity would you continue to pursue” thing

I would recommend finding a new topic for one of them. In very few cases is it ever a good idea to write multiple essays on one topic.

Do you mean the community essay? If so choose another community you belong to. For example if you wrote about in Your personal statement being part of the community of theater kids, write about for example being part of a community based on your personality characteristics “I’m one of the extroverts” or " I’m one of the risk takers" based on your academic style " I’m one of the ‘hands up’ guys ( I.e, you ask a lot of questions) etc…