Good evening everyone! When I posted the original question many months ago, I was absolutely clueless! Now DD is at the end of the application cycle, and I wanted to share where she ended up applying, along with the results. She didn’t apply ED anywhere.
Her profile is listed in the first post. We did not qualify for any Financial Aid. All scholarship amounts listed below are yearly.
RESULTS:
University of Pittsburgh: Accepted - Applied for Guaranteed Admissions Program to med school (did not receive) and Chancellor’s (did not receive) $10K per year awarded
University of South Florida: Accepted - National Merit (full-ride)
Texas A&M: Accepted - Opportunity Award Recipient (1k one-time), applied for Brown Scholars (not selected)
University of Texas at Dallas: Accepted - National Merit (full-ride)
UNC Chapel Hill: Accepted - Morehead-Cain Recipient (full-ride + much much more) 
University of Miami: Accepted - President’s Scholarship (25k per year), HPMP recipient, total $30,500 per year
University of Virginia: Accepted - Jefferson Finalist (did not receive)
University of Richmond: Accepted - Richmond Scholar Recipient (full-ride)
University of Florida: Accepted - Applied for Stamps (did not receive)
University of Maryland: Accepted - President’s Scholarship (12k per year), not selected for Banneker/Key
University of Houston: Accepted - National Merit (full tuition + fees), Academic Excellence Scholarship Recipient (in-state tuition and 6k per year)
UT Austin: Accepted - Applied for Forty Acres (did not receive)
Tulane: Accepted - Applied for TRIA, Deans’ Honor, Paul Tulane, and Pathway to Medicine (did not receive) - BTU Scholarship Recipient (1k), Merit Award (25k per year), Community Service Fellowship Recipient (8k per year)
Emory: Accepted - Applied for Woodruff Scholars (did not receive) $15K per year scholarship
University of Rochester: Accepted - Bausch + Lomb Scholarship Recipient (25k per year)
Duke: Accepted - Robertson Semifinalist (did not receive) $46,610 scholarship
Harvard: Accepted
Washington University in St. Louis: Accepted - Applied for Rodriguez, Ervin, and Danforth Scholars Programs (did not receive) $43,732 scholarship
Case Western Reserve: Waitlisted
Yale: Waitlisted
Princeton: Waitlisted
Stanford: Waitlisted
Final Decision: The real decision was between accepting the Morehead Cain at UNC or going to Harvard. For a multitude of reasons (which deserve a separate post), she chose the Morehead Cain at UNC Chapel Hill.
I appreciate everyone’s input on this over the past few months. It was a long, but fun journey, and she’s excited about the future as a Morehead Cain Scholar!
Thank you!