Great advice above. I will echo Lindagaf and MYOS - forget the dream schools (for now). First, focus on your safety. How about Lawrence in WI? St. Olaf? After you have a couple of schools you would be happy to attend (they don’t have to be your favorites but you can’t mentally say “they’re my safeties but I hope I don’t have to go there”). Then work on your matches. Reed is probably a solid match school for you but I suspect you think the school is too close to home.
It’s hard to give recommendations without knowing cost limits. If you need merit, that leads to a very different list than if you have no upper cost limit or if you qualify for need-based aid.