<p>“If your kid goes to a second tier college – the type of place that may give him merit aid – he’ll still be getting those kind of assignments that he’ll find mind-numbing, but that other students may need. I’m saying this as a former prof at a second tier. I had to give assignments like having students write chapter summaries because otherwise, they wouldn’t read the chapters or I wouldn’t know that they didn’t understand things that I thought were easy.”</p>
<p>I need to modify my statement above. From my older S’s experience attending a second tier public, and my experience teaching at 2 second tier publics, the above is true. I don’t think the above is true for second tier LACs.</p>
<p>Younger S attends a second tier private LAC, Rollins College, which is in lovely Winter Park, a 10 min. drive outside of Orlando, and his assignments were as challenging and even more challenging than many that I had at Harvard. As is the case with most LACs, it is very writing and critical-thinking intensive. Classes are small, professors are thoughtful and enjoy teaching. S has not had the boring make work types of assignments that he had in high school (even in AP and IB courses) and that his brother had at a 2nd tier public.</p>
<p>This S is getting an excellent, challenging education. H had a similar experience at Calvin College in Michigan, another second tier LAC.</p>
<p>The OP might want to check out Rollins as a possibility for her son. He probably would be in line for major merit aid, too due to his scores (even though its SAT-optional), grades, rigorous curriculum, and strong community service, something that Rollins is known for and values highly. Their top merit aid covers almost everything. My son didn’t get their top merit aid due, I believe, to his grades, which were below those of the OP’s S. </p>
<p>While Rollins is in a small city, the campus is right next to a main street with restaurants and other entertainment. The campus also is on a lake with a boat dock. It’s just at most a 10-min. drive from Orlando, which has lots of big city things to do.</p>