<p>Yes, some athletes do come in above the median, they don’t need a tip, but they still get the nod because they are an athlete. I actually have no problem with that. But you have to admit, in both Div I and Div III, there are a slew of athletes would not be at their schools were it not for their prowess with a ball.</p>
<p>I’ll reserve judgement on whether legacies are the most qualified applicant pool, but it is a possibility due to the fact that smart kids tend to have smart kids. However, given that back in the day, admissions to Harvard et al were not always meritorious, the possibility exists that some not so bright people got in as well.</p>