I have a CALS fact sheet about the incoming fall 2016 students from a visit. The admit rate for 2016 was 13% for CALS overall and there are 675 first year students in the incoming fall 2016 CALS class. Even if NY students have an advantage (which is unclear), it’s still a lottery for both in and out-of-state. Not trying to be discouraging, but keep in mind the odds!
A 35 ACT does put you in the top 25% for CALS ACT scores. Their middle 50% for the fall 2016 class according to the fact sheet was 29-33.