I think waiting tables could be good - and hey restaurants need help.
If one is outgoing, they’ll inevitably have conversations with customers and you never know who you meet - and how they might help you.
I think there’s a difference from a student who sought a job vs. one who didn’t but now seeks. As I moved my daughter out the other day, her graduating roommate - when I asked - what will you do - it was, I need to apply to some things - that’s a program in the Northeast that looks interesting - so this person doesn’t have the energy, drive or desire to have actually find something whereas others - have been looking and struggle.
I think work experience always beats over things - so I’d rather someone work at Gap or Kroger or wait tables or whatever then volunteering as a primary item.
Just like my son got far more intern offers his 2nd summer after struggling to land something his first summer and finding something last minute - I think experience begets more experience.
But I also think that many kids need to realize life isn’t as all as they think. For example, my daughter has a job in civil rights this summer - something she is passionate about. But when I read the job description, it’s more like data analysis in regards to state contracts - what % applying for these contracts are women and minorities. I imagine that will catapult to someone (hopefully including her) as to strategies to increase participation from these underrepresented groups.
But I know when my daughter first saw the job and civil rights - she wasn’t thinking data analysis but more like marching on the state capitol with signs in protest of the state government she doesn’t necessarily support.
So for someone with a liberal art degree that really doesn’t know what they want to do - it’s jobs like insurance claims or sales or customer service in a call center - that might be a realistic setting.
On the flip side, if they went to school for four years but did not get experience. Or if they did not spend their senior year busting tail to find a job…well it’s going to be harder now.
And every situation - depending on the student, major, past experiences, and previous job search efforts etc. probably would need to be handled differently.
Best of luck to all still seeking employment.